Lindenfeld T N, Hewett T E, Andriacchi T P
Cincinnati Sportsmedicine, OH, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1997 Nov(344):290-7.
The purpose of this study was to determine whether a brace designed to unload varus degenerative knees actually alters medial compartment loads by decreasing the adduction moment. Eleven patients who had arthrosis confined to the medial compartment were fitted with a valgus brace and tested before and after brace wear with pain and function scoring instruments and by automated gait analysis. The biomechanical data from these patients were compared with those from 11 healthy control subjects. Scores from an analog pain scale decreased 48% with brace wear, and function with activities of daily living increased 79%. Mean adduction moment without the brace measured 4.0 +/- 0.8% body weight times height versus 3.6 +/- 0.8% body weight times height when wearing the brace (10% decrease). The mean adduction moment for control subjects was 3.5 +/- 0.6% body weight times height. Thus, the mean adduction moment decreased from approximately one standard deviation from the normal mean to a value that is similar to the control value. Nine of 11 patients had a decrease in the adduction moment with the brace, five of 11 patients had a reduction higher than 10%, and decreases in this moment were as high as 32%. This study shows that pain, function, and biomechanical knee loading can be altered by a brace designed to unload the medial compartment of the knee.
本研究的目的是确定一种旨在减轻膝内翻退行性膝关节负荷的支具是否通过降低内收力矩来实际改变内侧间室负荷。11例仅内侧间室患有关节病的患者佩戴外翻支具,并在佩戴支具前后使用疼痛和功能评分工具以及通过自动步态分析进行测试。将这些患者的生物力学数据与11名健康对照受试者的数据进行比较。佩戴支具后,模拟疼痛量表评分下降了48%,日常生活活动功能提高了79%。不佩戴支具时的平均内收力矩为4.0±0.8%体重×身高,而佩戴支具时为3.6±0.8%体重×身高(下降10%)。对照受试者的平均内收力矩为3.5±0.6%体重×身高。因此,平均内收力矩从比正常平均值高出约一个标准差降至与对照值相似的值。11例患者中有9例佩戴支具后内收力矩下降,11例患者中有5例下降超过10%,且该力矩下降高达32%。本研究表明,一种旨在减轻膝关节内侧间室负荷的支具可以改变疼痛、功能和膝关节生物力学负荷。