Horowitz B Z, Matheny L
Division of Emergency Medicine, University of California, Davis, Medical Center, Sacramento, USA.
West J Med. 1997 Dec;167(6):392-7.
To assess the willingness of physicians and nurses with training in basic cardiac life support to provide mouth-to-mouth resuscitation in both hospital and out-of-hospital settings, we surveyed all attendees at a monthly advanced life support course over a 1-year period. Of 622 attendees, 379 (61%) responded to our survey describing a variety of cardiac arrest scenarios. Less than half of the participants surveyed were willing to do mouth-to-mouth resuscitation on an unknown adult, male or female, who had collapsed in a supermarket. Overall, the group was willing to do mouth-to-mouth resuscitation on victims known to them: their neighbors (84%), children at a pool (88%), spouses (94%), and parents (93%). In the hospital setting, knowing a patient's human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) status greatly influenced the willingness to do mouth-to-mouth rescue. If a patient's HIV status was unknown, only a third of providers would do mouth-to-mouth resuscitation; if the HIV status was known to be negative, two thirds would do mouth-to-mouth resuscitation (P < 0.002), Children in the hospital whose HIV status was unknown would receive mouth-to-mouth resuscitation by 57% of the respondents. Children known to be HIV-negative would be resuscitated by 79% of the respondents. Co-workers were more willing to resuscitate a known physician or nurse than an unknown co-worker, with physicians more willing than nurses to do mouth-to-mouth resuscitation on an unknown co-worker. A third of the group has performed mouth-to-mouth resuscitation previously. Although an increased percentage of this subgroup was willing to provide mouth-to-mouth in all adult hospital scenarios, experienced providers of mouth-to-mouth wanted to receive mouth-to-mouth resuscitation less frequently (75%) than inexperienced providers (84%) (P = 0.02). The self-reported willingness to provide mouth-to-mouth resuscitation is influenced by patient characteristics; as the level of familiarity with the victim decreased, so did the willingness of the health care professional to do mouth-to-mouth.
为了评估接受过基本心脏生命支持培训的医生和护士在医院和院外环境中进行口对口复苏的意愿,我们在1年的时间里对每月一次的高级生命支持课程的所有参与者进行了调查。在622名参与者中,379人(61%)回复了我们的调查,描述了各种心脏骤停场景。接受调查的参与者中,不到一半愿意对在超市晕倒的身份不明的成年男性或女性进行口对口复苏。总体而言,该群体愿意对他们认识的受害者进行口对口复苏:邻居(84%)、游泳池里的儿童(88%)、配偶(94%)和父母(93%)。在医院环境中,了解患者的人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)状况极大地影响了进行口对口急救的意愿。如果患者的HIV状况不明,只有三分之一的医护人员会进行口对口复苏;如果已知HIV状况为阴性,三分之二的人会进行口对口复苏(P<0.002)。医院中HIV状况不明的儿童会得到57%的受访者进行口对口复苏。已知HIV阴性的儿童会得到79%的受访者进行复苏。同事们更愿意对认识的医生或护士进行复苏,而不是对不认识的同事进行复苏,医生比护士更愿意对不认识的同事进行口对口复苏。三分之一的群体之前进行过口对口复苏。尽管该亚组中有更高比例的人愿意在所有成人医院场景中进行口对口复苏,但有经验的口对口提供者希望接受口对口复苏的频率(75%)低于无经验的提供者(84%)(P = 0.02)。自我报告的进行口对口复苏的意愿受患者特征影响;随着对受害者熟悉程度的降低,医护人员进行口对口复苏的意愿也随之降低。