Carlson G D, Minato Y, Okada A, Gorden C D, Warden K E, Barbeau J M, Biro C L, Bahnuik E, Bohlman H H, Lamanna J C
University Hospitals Spine Institute, The Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Cleveland, Ohio 44106, USA.
J Neurotrauma. 1997 Dec;14(12):951-62. doi: 10.1089/neu.1997.14.951.
Although surgical decompression is often advocated for acute spinal cord injury, the timing and efficacy of early treatment have not been clinically proven. Our objectives were to determine the importance of early spinal cord decompression on recovery of evoked potential conduction under precision loading conditions and to determine if regional vascular mechanisms could be linked to electrophysiologic recovery. Twenty-one mature beagles were anesthetized and mechanically ventilated to maintain normal respiratory and acid-base balance. Somatosensory-evoked potentials from the upper and lower extremities were measured at regular intervals. The spinal cord at T-13 was loaded dorsally under precision loading conditions until evoked potential amplitudes had been reduced by 50%. At this functional endpoint, spinal cord displacement was maintained for either 30 (n = 7), 60 (n = 8), or 180 min (n = 6). Spinal cord decompression was followed by a 3-h monitoring period. Regional spinal cord blood flow was measured with fluorescent microspheres at baseline (following laminectomy) immediately after stopping dynamic cord compression, 5, 15, and 180 min after decompression. Within 5 min after stopping dynamic compression, evoked potential signals were absent in all dogs. We observed somatosensory-evoked potential recovery in 6 of 7 dogs in the 30-min compression group, 5 of 8 dogs in the 60-min compression group, and 0 of 6 dogs in the 180-min compression group. Recovery in the 30- and 60-min groups varied significantly from the 180-min group (p < 0.05). Regional spinal cord blood flow at baseline, 21.4+/-2.2 ml/100/g/min (combined group mean +/- SE) decreased to 4.1+/-0.7 ml/100 g/min after stopping dynamic compression. Reperfusion flows after decompression were inversely related to duration of compression. Of the 7 dogs in the 30 min compression group, 5 min after decompression the blood flow was 49.1+/-3.1 ml/100 g/min, which was greater than two times baseline. In the 180-min compression group early post-decompression blood flow, 19.8+/-6.2 ml/100 g/min, was not significantly different than baseline. Of the 8 dogs in the 60-min compression group, 5 who recovered evoked potential conduction revealed a lower spinal cord blood flow sampled immediately after stopping dynamic compression, 2.1+/-0.4 ml/100 g/min, compared to the 3 who did not recover where blood flow was 8.4+/-2.1 ml/100 g/min (p < 0.05). Reperfusion flows measured as the interval change in blood flow between the time dynamic compression was stopped to 5, 15, or 180 min after decompression, were significantly greater in those dogs that recovered evoked potential function (p < 0.05). Three hours after decompression, spinal cord blood flow in the 3 dogs in the 60-min compression group with no recovery, 11.1+/-2.1 ml/100 g/min, was significantly less than the spinal cord blood flow of the recovered group (n = 5), 20.5+/-2.2 ml/100 g/min. These data illustrate the importance of early time-dependent events following precision dynamic spinal cord loading and sustained compression conditions. Spinal cord decompression performed within 1 h of evoked potential loss resulted in significant electrophysiologic recovery after 3 h of monitoring. This study showed that the degree of early reperfusion hyperemia after decompression was inversely proportional to the duration of spinal cord compression and proportional to electrophysiologic recovery. Residual blood flow during the sustained compression period was significantly higher in those dogs that did not recover evoked potential function after decompression suggesting a reperfusion injury. These results indicate that, after precise dynamic spinal cord loading to a point of functional conduction deficit (50% decline in evoked potential amplitude), a critical time period exists where intervention in the form of early spinal cord decompression can lead to effective recovery of electrophysiologic function in the 1- to 3-h post-decompression p
尽管手术减压常被推荐用于急性脊髓损伤,但早期治疗的时机和疗效尚未得到临床证实。我们的目的是确定在精确加载条件下早期脊髓减压对诱发电位传导恢复的重要性,并确定局部血管机制是否与电生理恢复有关。21只成年比格犬被麻醉并进行机械通气以维持正常呼吸和酸碱平衡。定期测量上肢和下肢的体感诱发电位。在精确加载条件下从背部对T-13脊髓进行加载,直到诱发电位幅度降低50%。在这个功能终点,脊髓移位维持30分钟(n = 7)、�0分钟(n = 8)或180分钟(n = 6)。脊髓减压后进行3小时的监测期。在基线(椎板切除术后)、停止动态脊髓压迫后立即、减压后5分钟、15分钟和180分钟,用荧光微球测量局部脊髓血流量。在停止动态压迫后5分钟内,所有犬的诱发电位信号均消失。我们观察到,在30分钟压迫组的7只犬中有6只、60分钟压迫组的8只犬中有5只、180分钟压迫组的6只犬中有0只出现体感诱发电位恢复。30分钟和60分钟组的恢复情况与180分钟组有显著差异(p < 0.05)。基线时局部脊髓血流量为21.4±2.2 ml/100/g/min(合并组均值±标准误),停止动态压迫后降至4.1±0.7 ml/100 g/min。减压后的再灌注流量与压迫持续时间呈负相关。在30分钟压迫组的7只犬中,减压后5分钟血流量为49.1±3.1 ml/100 g/min,大于基线的两倍。在180分钟压迫组,减压后早期血流量为19.8±6.2 ml/100 g/min,与基线无显著差异。在60分钟压迫组的8只犬中,5只恢复诱发电位传导的犬在停止动态压迫后立即采集的脊髓血流量较低,为2.1±0.4 ml/100 g/min,而3只未恢复的犬血流量为8.4±2.1 ml/100 g/min(p < 0.05)。以停止动态压迫至减压后5分钟、15分钟或180分钟之间的血流间隔变化来衡量的再灌注流量在恢复诱发电位功能的犬中显著更高(p < 0.05)。减压3小时后,60分钟压迫组中3只未恢复的犬的脊髓血流量为11.1±2.1 ml/100 g/min,显著低于恢复组(n = 5)的脊髓血流量20.5±2.2 ml/100 g/min。这些数据说明了在精确动态脊髓加载和持续压迫条件下早期时间依赖性事件的重要性。在诱发电位丧失后1小时内进行脊髓减压,在监测3小时后可导致显著的电生理恢复。本研究表明,减压后早期再灌注充血程度与脊髓压迫持续时间成反比,与电生理恢复成正比。在持续压迫期间,减压后未恢复诱发电位功能的犬的残余血流量显著更高,提示存在再灌注损伤。这些结果表明,在将脊髓精确动态加载至功能传导缺陷点(诱发电位幅度下降50%)后,存在一个关键时间段,在此期间以早期脊髓减压形式进行干预可导致减压后1至3小时内电生理功能有效恢复。