Ohlemeyer C L, Hornberger L L, Lynch D A, Swierkosz E M
Department of Pediatrics, St. Louis University School of Medicine, Missouri, USA.
J Adolesc Health. 1998 Mar;22(3):205-8. doi: 10.1016/s1054-139x(97)00214-0.
This study compared the InPouch TV culture to wet-mount, Diamond's culture medium, and Papanicolaou (Pap) smear for the diagnosis of trichomonas infection in sexually active adolescents.
A total of 467 subjects were recruited among 12-18-year-old girls who received pelvic examinations at two urban adolescent clinics. All girls were tested by wet-mount and InPouch TV. In addition 339 of 467 had cultures in Diamond's medium and 366 of 467 had Pap smears. Specimens were collected for InPouch TV and Diamond's cultures and read at 24-48 h and 5 days, and in the case of Diamond's cultures, also at 7 days. In a subset of subjects (268 of 467) who had all four tests done, sensitivities and specificities were calculated using Diamond's culture as the "gold standard."
In the 467 subjects, 73 (15.6%) tested positive for trichomonas by at least one method. In the subset with all four tests done, sensitivities of the wet-mount and InPouch TV were 36% and 81%, respectively; while that of the Pap smear was 56%. The culture media were equally efficient in identifying Trichomonas vaginalis. There were no differences found between subjects with or without trichomonas infections in gynecological symptoms, previous history of sexually transmitted diseases, or use of a condom at last intercourse.
InPouch TV culture is a good diagnostic method for T. vaginalis because of its long shelf-life, relatively low expense, and high sensitivity (over twice as sensitive as wet-mount).
本研究比较了InPouch TV培养法与湿片法、戴蒙德培养基培养法及巴氏涂片法在诊断性活跃青少年滴虫感染中的应用。
在两家城市青少年诊所接受盆腔检查的12至18岁女孩中,共招募了467名受试者。所有女孩均接受了湿片法和InPouch TV检测。此外,467名受试者中的339名进行了戴蒙德培养基培养,467名中的366名进行了巴氏涂片检查。采集样本用于InPouch TV和戴蒙德培养基培养,并分别在24至48小时及5天时进行观察,对于戴蒙德培养基培养,还在7天时进行观察。在进行了所有四项检测的部分受试者(467名中的268名)中,以戴蒙德培养基培养法为“金标准”计算敏感性和特异性。
在467名受试者中,73名(15.6%)至少通过一种方法检测出滴虫阳性。在进行了所有四项检测的子集中,湿片法和InPouch TV的敏感性分别为36%和81%;巴氏涂片法的敏感性为56%。两种培养基在鉴定阴道毛滴虫方面同样有效。在有无滴虫感染的受试者之间,妇科症状、既往性传播疾病史或上次性交时是否使用避孕套方面均未发现差异。
InPouch TV培养法是诊断阴道毛滴虫的一种良好方法,因其保质期长、费用相对较低且敏感性高(比湿片法敏感两倍以上)。