Krupp E, Löscher W
Department of Pharmacology, Toxicology, and Pharmacy, School of Veterinary Medicine, Hannover, Germany.
J Pharmacol Exp Ther. 1998 Jun;285(3):1137-49.
A modified cortical ramp stimulation (CRS) model has been developed allowing repeated determinations of seizure threshold at short time intervals in individual rats without inducing postictal threshold increases. Anticonvulsant potency of the standard antiepileptic drugs carbamazepine, phenytoin, phenobarbital, valproate, diazepam and ethosuximide in the CRS model was compared with respective drug potencies in two more traditional seizure models with transcorneal stimulus application, i.e., the minimal electroshock seizure threshold (minEST) and the maximal electroshock seizure threshold (maxEST). In the CRS model, two different types of threshold were determined, the threshold for localized seizures (TLS) and the threshold for generalized seizures (TGS). When screw electrodes were implanted over the primary motor cortex, TLS was characterized by unilateral forelimb clonus, tonic abduction of contralateral forelimb, and head adversion. When ramp-shaped stimulation was continued above the TLS current, bilateral clonic forelimb seizures with loss of posture developed, which was defined as TGS. In contrast to TLS, TGS could not be repeatedly determined at short time intervals because of postictal threshold increase. TLS was dose-dependently increased by carbamazepine, phenobarbital, valproate and diazepam, although phenytoin showed a truncated dose-response, and ethosuximide was ineffective. In comparison to TLS, drug-induced increases in TGS were more marked. All drugs dose-dependently increased minEST and, except ethosuximide, maxEST. For comparison of drug potencies, doses increasing seizure thresholds by 20 or 50% were calculated from dose-response curves. Respective comparisons showed marked differences in drug potencies between models, indicating that the CRS method presents a model of another, more pharmacoresistant seizure type than seizure types induced in traditional models, such as transcorneal electroshock. Based on the location of electrodes in the frontal neocortex, the characteristic seizure pattern, and the low pharmacological sensitivity of the seizures to standard antiepileptics, the modified CRS model most likely represents a new model of localization-related seizures occurring in frontal lobe epilepsy and may thus be used in the search for novel drugs with higher efficacy against this difficult-to-treat type of epilepsy.
已开发出一种改良的皮质斜坡刺激(CRS)模型,可在个体大鼠中短时间间隔内重复测定癫痫发作阈值,且不会引起发作后阈值升高。将标准抗癫痫药物卡马西平、苯妥英、苯巴比妥、丙戊酸盐、地西泮和乙琥胺在CRS模型中的抗惊厥效力与在另外两种经角膜刺激应用的传统癫痫发作模型(即最小电休克癫痫发作阈值(minEST)和最大电休克癫痫发作阈值(maxEST))中的相应药物效力进行了比较。在CRS模型中,测定了两种不同类型的阈值,即局灶性癫痫发作阈值(TLS)和全身性癫痫发作阈值(TGS)。当将螺旋电极植入初级运动皮层上方时,TLS的特征为单侧前肢阵挛、对侧前肢强直性外展和头部转向。当斜坡形刺激持续高于TLS电流时,会出现双侧阵挛性前肢癫痫发作并伴有姿势丧失,这被定义为TGS。与TLS不同,由于发作后阈值升高,TGS无法在短时间间隔内重复测定。卡马西平、苯巴比妥、丙戊酸盐和地西泮使TLS剂量依赖性增加,尽管苯妥英显示出截断的剂量反应,而乙琥胺无效。与TLS相比,药物诱导的TGS升高更为明显。所有药物均使minEST剂量依赖性增加,除乙琥胺外,还使maxEST增加。为了比较药物效力,根据剂量反应曲线计算出使癫痫发作阈值提高20%或50%的剂量。各自比较显示模型之间药物效力存在显著差异,表明CRS方法呈现出一种与传统模型(如经角膜电休克)诱导的癫痫发作类型不同的、对药物更具抗性的癫痫发作模型。基于电极在额叶新皮层中的位置、特征性癫痫发作模式以及癫痫发作对标准抗癫痫药物的低药理学敏感性,改良的CRS模型很可能代表了额叶癫痫中发生的与定位相关癫痫发作的新模型,因此可用于寻找对这种难治性癫痫类型具有更高疗效的新型药物。