Wentworth K, Crabtree J, Mitchell J, Boulger J
University of Minnesota-Duluth School of Medicine, USA.
Minn Med. 1998 Jun;81(6):39-44.
Prepaid managed care medicine has become dominant in urban Minnesota and is making its way into the rural setting. This study assesses the attitudes of rural family practice physicians in Minnesota toward managed care. A survey, consisting primarily of five-point Likert scale statements, was mailed to 798 rural Minnesota family practice physicians, with a response rate of 35% (281 respondents). We tabulated overall responses and made comparisons based on practice characteristics and years in practice. Twenty physicians participated in a follow-up telephone interview. We also conducted telephone interviews with 10 representatives from managed care organizations. Both positive and negative attitudes toward managed care emerged. Two-thirds of respondents did not feel that their time with patients was diminished under managed care. However, 67% of respondents felt that managed care organizations had failed to incorporate rural patients' specific needs into their policies. Only 7% of respondents felt that managed care organizations adequately explained their benefits packages to enrollees. Rural family practitioners' apparent disillusionment with current managed care models merits the attention of those concerned with medical care in rural areas.
预付费管理式医疗在明尼苏达州的城市地区已占据主导地位,并正逐渐进入农村地区。本研究评估了明尼苏达州农村家庭医生对管理式医疗的态度。一项主要由五点李克特量表陈述组成的调查被邮寄给了798名明尼苏达州农村家庭医生,回复率为35%(281名受访者)。我们将总体回复制成表格,并根据执业特点和执业年限进行了比较。20名医生参与了后续的电话访谈。我们还对10名管理式医疗组织的代表进行了电话访谈。对管理式医疗出现了积极和消极两种态度。三分之二的受访者认为在管理式医疗模式下他们与患者相处的时间没有减少。然而,67%的受访者认为管理式医疗组织未能将农村患者的特殊需求纳入其政策中。只有7%的受访者认为管理式医疗组织向参保人充分解释了他们的福利套餐。农村家庭医生对当前管理式医疗模式明显的失望值得关注农村医疗的人士重视。