Capoferri M, Furrer M, Ris H B
Universitätsklinik für Thorax-, Herz- und Gefässchirurgie, Inselspital Bern.
Swiss Surg. 1998;4(3):121-8.
The diagnostic and therapeutic approach in patients with mediastinal masses (MM) treated at our institute between 1983 and 1993 was retrospectively reviewed.
193 patients with MM (105 males and 88 females, average age 53, ranging from 16-81) underwent 223 interventions. Staging mediastinoscopies in lung cancer patients were ruled out. Long-term follow-up data were available in 123 of 162 cases with neoplastic MM (average follow-up time 5.5 years). Of all 223 surgical interventions 143 were diagnostic (53 parasternal mediastinotomies, 78 mediastinoscopies and 8 thoracoscopies) and 80 therapeutic (46 sternotomies and 34 posterolateral and a second half). The analysed period was splitted up in a first half (1983-1987) and second half (1988-1993) to study an eventual trend in the management of MM.
The most frequent diagnoses were: thymoma (21%), malignant lymphoma (18%) and mediastinal sarcoidosis (14%). 43% of the MM were localized in the anterior, 46% in the middle and 7% in the posterior mediastinum. Thoracic pain, cough and dyspnoea represented the most common symptoms, leading to an invasive diagnostic procedure. 25% of the patients had no symptoms. The mortality and morbidity rate of all interventions was 3.4% and 18.7% respectively and concerned almost nerval injuries and postoperative respiratory failure. The percentage of direct tumor excisions increased from 21% during the first half of the period to 40% during the second half of the period, whereas diagnostic surgical interventions decreased from 57% to 44%. The percentage of total excisions after previous surgical biopsies decreased from 22% to 16%. In spite of the introduction of high resolution CT scan and MRI techniques during this time period no significant change in the use of presurgical diagnostic procedures was obvious. Fine needle biopsies and bronchoscopies were performed less frequent in the second half in comparison to the first half (11%, 7%, 29%, 13% respectively). From 123 patients with neoplastic disease data were available for long-term results. 35 had benign and 83 malignant histologies, in five cases dignity was unclear. 54% of these patients were disease-free at follow-up time, 10% had local recurrency or distant metastasis and 37% died during the observed time period.
Surgical biopsy seems to remain the most important investigation for a successful interdisciplinary approach to MM. Overall morbidity and mortality rate of mediastinal surgery might appear remarkable but has to be related to the favorous long-term results after different individual treatment modalities in patients with mediastinal masses.
回顾性分析了1983年至1993年在我院接受治疗的纵隔肿物(MM)患者的诊断和治疗方法。
193例MM患者(男性105例,女性88例,平均年龄53岁,年龄范围16 - 81岁)接受了223次干预。排除肺癌患者的分期纵隔镜检查。162例肿瘤性MM患者中有123例有长期随访数据(平均随访时间5.5年)。在所有223例手术干预中,143例为诊断性手术(53例胸骨旁纵隔切开术、78例纵隔镜检查和8例胸腔镜检查),80例为治疗性手术(46例胸骨切开术和34例后外侧手术及另一半手术)。分析期分为前半期(1983 - 1987年)和后半期(1988 - 1993年),以研究MM治疗管理中的最终趋势。
最常见的诊断为:胸腺瘤(21%)、恶性淋巴瘤(18%)和纵隔结节病(14%)。43%的MM位于前纵隔,46%位于中纵隔,7%位于后纵隔。胸痛、咳嗽和呼吸困难是最常见的症状,导致进行侵入性诊断程序。25%的患者无症状。所有干预的死亡率和发病率分别为3.4%和18.7%,主要涉及神经损伤和术后呼吸衰竭。直接肿瘤切除的百分比从该时期前半期的21%增加到后半期的40%,而诊断性手术干预从57%降至44%。先前手术活检后完全切除的百分比从22%降至16%。尽管在此期间引入了高分辨率CT扫描和MRI技术,但术前诊断程序的使用没有明显变化。后半期细针活检和支气管镜检查的执行频率低于前半期(分别为11%、7%、29%、13%)。123例肿瘤性疾病患者有长期结果数据。35例为良性组织学,83例为恶性组织学,5例性质不明。这些患者中54%在随访时无疾病,10%有局部复发或远处转移,37%在观察期内死亡。
手术活检似乎仍然是成功进行MM多学科治疗的最重要检查。纵隔手术的总体发病率和死亡率可能看起来较高,但必须与纵隔肿物患者不同个体治疗方式后的良好长期结果相关。