McGahan J R, Williamson J D, Stoecker J
Department of Psychology, Northeast Louisiana University, Monroe 71209-1110, USA.
Percept Mot Skills. 1998 Jun;86(3 Pt 2):1459-68. doi: 10.2466/pms.1998.86.3c.1459.
Intuitive judgements about covariations of length, weight, and width were assessed in two experiments using a series of propositional statements. In Exp. 1, only a priori judgements were rendered, whereas in Exp. 2 blindfolded participants physically manipulated and described a series of objects varying on these dimensions before rendering their judgements. Analyses indicated participants judged weight and width as positively correlated, length and weight as uncorrelated and, to some extent, length and width as negatively correlated. If judgements are rendered after the haptic exploration phase, weight and width are (again) judged as positively correlated, and length and weight were still judged as uncorrelated. However, after the database intervention. length and width were judged as positively correlated. Results are discussed relative to research on reasoning about covariation and belief perseveration as well as perceived covariations between height, weight, and body fat.
在两项实验中,使用一系列命题陈述对关于长度、重量和宽度协变的直观判断进行了评估。在实验1中,仅做出了先验判断,而在实验2中,蒙住眼睛的参与者在做出判断之前对一系列在这些维度上变化的物体进行了实际操作和描述。分析表明,参与者判断重量和宽度呈正相关,长度和重量不相关,并且在一定程度上长度和宽度呈负相关。如果在触觉探索阶段之后做出判断,重量和宽度(再次)被判断为正相关,长度和重量仍然被判断为不相关。然而,在数据库干预之后,长度和宽度被判断为正相关。相对于关于协变推理和信念坚持以及身高、体重和体脂之间感知协变的研究,对结果进行了讨论。