Tampellini M, Filipski E, Liu X H, Lemaigre G, Li X M, Vrignaud P, François E, Bissery M C, Lévi F
Laboratoire Rythmes Biologiques et Chronothérapeutique (Université Paris XI), Institut du Cancer et d'Immunogénétique, Hôpital Paul Brousse, Villejuif, France.
Cancer Res. 1998 Sep 1;58(17):3896-904.
Docetaxel tolerance and antitumor efficacy could be enhanced if drug administration was adapted to circadian rhythms. This hypothesis was investigated in seven experiments involving a total of 626 male B6D2F1 mice, synchronized with an alternation of 12 h of light and 12 h of darkness (12:12), after i.v. administration of docetaxel. In experiment (Exp) 1, the drug was given once a week (wk) for 6 wks (20 mg/kg/wk) or for 5 wks (30 mg/kg/wk) at one of six circadian times, during light when mice were resting [3, 7, or 11 hours after light onset (HALO)], or during darkness, when mice were active (15, 19, or 23 HALO). Endpoints were survival and body weight change. In Exp 2 and 3, docetaxel (30 mg/kg/wk) was administered twice, 1 wk apart, at one of four circadian stages (7, 11, 19, or 23 HALO). Endpoints were hematological and intestinal toxicities. In Exp 4, circadian changes in cell cycle phase distribution and BCL-2 immunofluorescence were investigated in bone marrow as possible mechanisms of docetaxel tolerability rhythm. In Exp 5 to 7, docetaxel was administered to mice bearing measurable P03 pancreatic adenocarcinoma (270-370 mg), with tumor weight and survival as endpoints. Mice from Exp 5 and 6 received a weekly schedule of docetaxel at one of six circadian stages (20 or 30 mg/kg/wk at 3, 7, 11, 15, 19, or 23 HALO). In Exp 7, docetaxel (30 mg/kg) was given every 2 days (day 1, 3, 5 schedule) at 7, 11, 19, or 23 HALO. Docetaxel dosing in the second half of darkness (19 or 23 HALO) resulted in significantly worse toxicity than its administration during the light span (3, 7, or 11 HALO). The survival rate ranged from 56.3% in the mice treated at 23 HALO to 93.8 or 87.5% in those injected at 3 or 11 HALO, respectively (Exp 1, P < 0.01). Granulocytopenia at nadir was -49 +/- 14% at 7 HALO compared with -84 +/- 3% at 19 HALO (Exp 2 and 3, P < 0.029), and severe jejunal mucosa necrosis occurred in 5 of 8 mice treated at 23 HALO as opposed to 2 of 18 receiving docetaxel at 7, 11, or 19 HALO (Exp 2 and 3, P < 0.02). The time of least docetaxel toxicity corresponded to the circadian nadir in S or G2-M phase and to the circadian maximum in BCL-2 immunofluorescence in bone marrow. Docetaxel increased the median survival of tumor-bearing mice in a dose-dependent manner (controls: 24 days; 20 mg/kg weekly, 33 days; 30 mg/kg weekly or day 1, 3, 5 schedule, 44 or 46 days, respectively; Exp 5-7). Survival curves of treated mice differed significantly according to dosing time for each dose and schedule (P from log rank <0.003 to P < 0.03). In Exp 5 and 6, the percentage of increase in life span was largest if docetaxel was administered weekly at 7 HALO (20 mg/kg, 220%; 30 mg/kg, 372%) and lowest after docetaxel dosing at 19 HALO (80% with 20 mg/kg) or at 15 HALO (78% with 30 mg/kg). In Exp 7, (day 1, 3, 5 schedule), docetaxel was most active at 11 HALO (percentage increase in life span, 390%) and least active at 23 HALO (210%). Docetaxel tolerability and antitumor efficacy were simultaneously enhanced by drug dosing in the light span, when mice were resting. Mechanisms underlying the tolerability rhythm likely involved the circadian organization of cell cycle regulation. Docetaxel therapeutic index may be improved with an administration at night in cancer patients, when fewest bone marrow cells are in S or G2-M phase.
如果药物给药适应昼夜节律,多西他赛的耐受性和抗肿瘤疗效可能会增强。在七项实验中对这一假设进行了研究,这些实验共涉及626只雄性B6D2F1小鼠,在静脉注射多西他赛后,使其适应12小时光照和12小时黑暗交替(12:12)的环境。在实验(Exp)1中,药物每周给药一次(wk),共6周(20毫克/千克/周)或5周(30毫克/千克/周),在六个昼夜节律时间之一给药,在光照期间小鼠休息时给药[光照开始后(HALO)3、7或11小时],或在黑暗期间小鼠活动时给药(15、19或23 HALO)。观察终点为生存率和体重变化。在实验2和3中,多西他赛(30毫克/千克/周)分两次给药,间隔1周,在四个昼夜节律阶段之一给药(7、11、19或23 HALO)。观察终点为血液学和肠道毒性。在实验4中,研究了骨髓中细胞周期阶段分布和BCL - 2免疫荧光的昼夜变化,作为多西他赛耐受性节律的可能机制。在实验5至7中,对患有可测量的P03胰腺腺癌(270 - 370毫克)的小鼠给予多西他赛,以肿瘤重量和生存率作为观察终点。实验5和6中的小鼠在六个昼夜节律阶段之一接受每周一次的多西他赛给药方案(在3、7、11、15、19或23 HALO时为20或30毫克/千克/周)。在实验7中,多西他赛(30毫克/千克)在7、11、19或23 HALO时每2天给药一次(第1、3、5天给药方案)。在黑暗后半段(19或23 HALO)给药多西他赛导致的毒性明显比在光照期间(3、7或11 HALO)给药更严重。生存率范围从在23 HALO治疗的小鼠中的56.3%到在3或11 HALO注射的小鼠中的93.8%或87.5%(实验1,P < 0.01)。在7 HALO时最低点的粒细胞减少为 - 49 ± 14%,而在19 HALO时为 - 84 ± 3%(实验2和3,P < 0.029),并且在23 HALO治疗的8只小鼠中有5只发生严重空肠黏膜坏死,而在7、11或19 HALO接受多西他赛治疗的18只小鼠中有2只发生(实验2和3,P < 0.02)。多西他赛毒性最小的时间对应于骨髓中S或G2 - M期的昼夜最低点以及BCL - 2免疫荧光的昼夜最大值。多西他赛以剂量依赖的方式增加了荷瘤小鼠的中位生存期(对照组:24天;每周20毫克/千克,33天;每周30毫克/千克或第1、3、5天给药方案,分别为44或46天;实验5 - 7)。根据每种剂量和给药方案的给药时间,治疗小鼠的生存曲线有显著差异(对数秩检验的P值从<0.003到P < 0.03)。在实验5和6中,如果在7 HALO每周给药多西他赛,寿命延长的百分比最大(20毫克/千克时为220%;30毫克/千克时为372%),而在19 HALO给药多西他赛后最低(20毫克/千克时为80%)或在15 HALO给药多西他赛后最低(30毫克/千克时为78%)。在实验7中(第1、3、5天给药方案),多西他赛在11 HALO时最有效(寿命延长百分比为390%),在23 HALO时最无效(210%)。当小鼠休息时,在光照期间给药多西他赛可同时提高其耐受性和抗肿瘤疗效。耐受性节律的潜在机制可能涉及细胞周期调节的昼夜组织。在癌症患者中,当处于S或G2 - M期的骨髓细胞最少时,在夜间给药可能会提高多西他赛的治疗指数。