Shear H L, Grinberg L, Gilman J, Fabry M E, Stamatoyannopoulos G, Goldberg D E, Nagel R L
Division of Hematology, Department of Medicine, Montefiore Medical Center/Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, NY 10467, USA.
Blood. 1998 Oct 1;92(7):2520-6.
Studies in vitro by Pasvol et al (Nature, 270:171, 1977) have indicated that the growth of Plasmodium falciparum in cells containing fetal hemoglobin (HbF = alpha2gamma2) is retarded, but invasion is increased, at least in newborn cells. Normal neonates switch from about 80% HbF at birth to a few percent at the end of the first year of life. Carriers of beta-thalassemia trait exhibit a delay in the normal HbF switch-off, which might partially explain the protection observed in populations with this gene. To study this hypothesis in vivo, we used transgenic (gamma) mice expressing human Agamma and Ggamma chains resulting in 40% to 60% alpha2Mgamma2 hemoglobin, infected with rodent malaria. Two species of rodent malaria were studied. P chabaudi adami causes a nonlethal infection, mainly in mature red blood cells (RBC). P yoelii 17XNL is a nonlethal infection, invading primarily reticulocytes, whereas P yoelii 17XL is a lethal variant of P yoelii 17XNL and causes death of mice in approximately 1 to 2 weeks. Data indicate that this strain may cause a syndrome resembling cerebral malaria caused by P falciparum (Am J Trop Med Hyg, 50:512, 1994). In gamma transgenic mice infected with P chabaudi adami, the parasitemia rose more quickly (in agreement with Pasvol) than in control mice, but was cleared more rapidly. In mice infected with P yoelii 17XNL, a clear reduction in parasitemia was observed. Interestingly, splenectomy before this infection, did not reverse protection. The most striking effect was in lethal P yoelii 17XL infection. Control mice died between 11 to 13 days, whereas gamma mice cleared the infection by day 22 and survived, a phenomenon also observed in splenectomized animals. These results suggest that HbF does indeed have a protective effect in vivo, which is not mediated by the spleen. In terms of mechanisms, light microscopy showed that intraerythrocytic parasites develop slowly in HbF erythrocytes, and electron microscopy showed that hemozoin formation was defective in transgenic mice. Finally, digestion studies of HbF by recombinant plasmepsin II demonstrated that HbF is digested only half as well as hemoglobin A (HbA). We conclude that HbF provides protection from P falciparum malaria by the retardation of parasite growth. The mechanism involves resistance to digestion by malarial hemoglobinases based on the data presented and with the well-known properties of HbF as a super stable tetramer. In addition, the resistance of normal neonates for malaria can now be explained by a double mechanism: increased malaria invasion rates, reported in neonatal RBC, will direct parasites to fetal cells, as well as F cells, and less to the approximately 20% of HbA containing RBC, amplifying the antimalarial effects of HbF.
帕斯沃尔等人(《自然》,270:171, 1977)的体外研究表明,恶性疟原虫在含有胎儿血红蛋白(HbF = α2γ2)的细胞中的生长受到抑制,但入侵能力增强,至少在新生细胞中如此。正常新生儿出生时约80%为HbF,到一岁末降至百分之几。β地中海贫血特征携带者正常的HbF关闭延迟,这可能部分解释了在具有该基因的人群中观察到的保护作用。为了在体内研究这一假说,我们使用了表达人Agamma和Ggamma链的转基因(γ)小鼠,其α2Mγ2血红蛋白含量为40%至60%,并用啮齿动物疟疾进行感染。研究了两种啮齿动物疟疾。夏氏疟原虫主要感染成熟红细胞,引发非致命性感染。约氏疟原虫17XNL是非致命性感染,主要入侵网织红细胞,而约氏疟原虫17XL是约氏疟原虫17XNL的致命变体,可在约1至2周内导致小鼠死亡。数据表明,该菌株可能引发类似恶性疟原虫所致脑型疟疾的综合征(《美国热带医学与卫生杂志》,50:512, 1994)。在感染夏氏疟原虫的γ转基因小鼠中,疟原虫血症上升速度比对照小鼠更快(与帕斯沃尔的研究结果一致),但清除速度也更快。在感染约氏疟原虫17XNL的小鼠中,观察到疟原虫血症明显降低。有趣的是,在此感染前进行脾切除并不能逆转这种保护作用。最显著的效果出现在致命的约氏疟原虫17XL感染中。对照小鼠在11至13天之间死亡,而γ小鼠在第22天时清除了感染并存活下来,在脾切除的动物中也观察到了这一现象。这些结果表明,HbF在体内确实具有保护作用,且这种作用不是由脾脏介导的。就机制而言,光学显微镜显示红细胞内寄生虫在HbF红细胞中发育缓慢,电子显微镜显示转基因小鼠中的疟色素形成存在缺陷。最后,重组胃蛋白酶II对HbF的消化研究表明,HbF的消化程度仅为血红蛋白A(HbA)的一半。我们得出结论,HbF通过延缓寄生虫生长为恶性疟原虫疟疾提供保护。根据所提供的数据以及HbF作为超稳定四聚体的已知特性,该机制涉及对疟原虫血红蛋白酶消化的抗性。此外,正常新生儿对疟疾的抵抗力现在可以通过双重机制来解释:新生儿红细胞中报道的疟疾入侵率增加,会将寄生虫导向胎儿细胞以及F细胞,而较少导向约20%含有HbA的红细胞,从而放大了HbF的抗疟作用。