Hannah S G, Turf E E, Fierro M F
Vanderbilt University School of Medicine, Nashville, Tennessee, USA.
Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 1998 Sep;19(3):275-83. doi: 10.1097/00000433-199809000-00016.
An empiric validation of a proposed typology of murder-suicide events was carried out in the Central District of the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner of Virginia for two cohorts, 1980 to 1984 and 1990 to 1994; use of a single typology allows description of trends in these events over time, a unique aspect of this study. For both cohorts, a total of 53 successful events with 63 victims (116 total deaths) was evaluated. A significant shift in the characteristics of location, perpetrators, and victimology of such events between the two cohorts is demonstrated: events changed from urban, multiple victim events with a majority of white perpetrators to rural, dyadic events in which victims did not live with perpetrators, the majority of whom were black. The results are compared with published data, and the implications for use of this typology as a clinical evaluation tool for prevention are addressed in light of current domestic violence emphases in public health. Additionally, the need for prospective tracking of these events is reiterated and use of the Hanzlick-Koponen typology as the tool for such tracking is suggested.
在弗吉尼亚州首席法医办公室中区,针对1980年至1984年以及1990年至1994年这两个队列,对所提出的谋杀自杀事件类型学进行了实证验证;使用单一类型学能够描述这些事件随时间的趋势,这是本研究的一个独特之处。对于这两个队列,总共评估了53起成功事件,涉及63名受害者(共116人死亡)。研究表明,这两个队列在此类事件的地点、犯罪者和受害者特征方面发生了显著变化:事件从城市多受害者事件转变为农村二元事件,受害者与犯罪者不住在一起,且犯罪者大多数为黑人。将结果与已发表的数据进行了比较,并根据当前公共卫生领域对家庭暴力的重视,探讨了使用这种类型学作为预防临床评估工具的意义。此外,重申了对这些事件进行前瞻性跟踪的必要性,并建议使用汉兹利克 - 科波宁类型学作为此类跟踪的工具。