Szabó G, Sebening C, Hackert T, Hagl C, Tochtermann U, Vahl C F, Hagl S
Department of Cardiac Surgery, University of Heidelberg, Germany.
J Heart Lung Transplant. 1998 Sep;17(9):921-30.
An increasing number of experimental and clinical studies reports hemodynamic instability in the donor organism after brain death. However, the relative importance of brain death-related cardiac dysfunction on posttransplantation cardiac function and the reversibility of the observed changes remain controversial. In this study a load-independent analysis of cardiac function after brain death was performed. Special interest was focused on a possible interactive influence of brain death and cardiac preservation on postischemic cardiac function.
In 12 anesthetized dogs, brain death was induced by inflation of a subdural balloon; 12 sham-operated animals served as control subjects. After a 2-hour observation in situ, the hearts were explanted and perfused parabiotically either immediately or after hypothermic ischemic preservation (4 hours, 4 degrees C). Heart rate, cardiac output, left ventricular pressure, the maximum of left ventricular pressure development and aortic pressure were measured in situ. In addition, the slope of the end-systolic pressure-volume relationship, coronary blood flow, and myocardial oxygen consumption were estimated in the cross-circulated hearts.
In spite of a brain death-associated hemodynamic deterioration in situ (expressed as low mean aortic pressure and significant decrease of maximal dP/dt), myocardial function was similar to control after explantation, if assessed ex vivo. Furthermore, after hypothermic ischemic preservation and reperfusion, complete functional recovery of control and brain-dead hearts could be observed.
These data indicate that hemodynamic instability after brain death may rather reflect altered loading conditions than irreversible myocardial damage or primary cardiac dysfunction. Furthermore, there is no evidence for a brain death-related impairment of ischemic tolerance.
越来越多的实验和临床研究报告称,脑死亡后供体机体存在血流动力学不稳定。然而,脑死亡相关的心功能障碍对移植后心功能的相对重要性以及所观察到的变化的可逆性仍存在争议。在本研究中,对脑死亡后的心脏功能进行了负荷独立分析。特别关注脑死亡和心脏保存对缺血后心脏功能可能的交互影响。
在12只麻醉的狗中,通过硬膜下球囊充气诱导脑死亡;12只假手术动物作为对照。原位观察2小时后,立即或在低温缺血保存(4小时,4℃)后取出心脏并进行联体灌注。在原位测量心率、心输出量、左心室压力、左心室压力上升最大值和主动脉压力。此外,在交叉循环的心脏中估计收缩末期压力-容积关系的斜率、冠状动脉血流量和心肌耗氧量。
尽管原位存在与脑死亡相关的血流动力学恶化(表现为平均主动脉压低和最大dP/dt显著降低),但如果进行离体评估,心肌功能在取出后与对照相似。此外,在低温缺血保存和再灌注后,可以观察到对照心脏和脑死亡心脏的功能完全恢复。
这些数据表明,脑死亡后的血流动力学不稳定可能更多地反映了负荷条件的改变,而不是不可逆的心肌损伤或原发性心功能障碍。此外,没有证据表明存在与脑死亡相关的缺血耐受性损害。