Dobrowsky W, Naudé J, Widder J, Dobrowsky E, Millesi W, Pavelka R, Grasl C, Reichel M
Department of Radiotherapy and Radiobiology, University of Vienna, Allgemeines Krankenhaus der Stadt Wien, Austria.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1998 Nov 1;42(4):803-6. doi: 10.1016/s0360-3016(98)00321-6.
To evaluate the effect of mitomycin C to an accelerated hyperfractionated radiation therapy. The aim was to test a very short schedule with/without mitomycin C (MMC) with conventional fractionation in histologically verified squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck region.
From October 1990 to December 1996, 188 patients entered the trial. Tumors originated in the oral cavity in 54, oropharynx in 82, larynx in 20, and hypopharynx in 32 cases, respectively. Patients' stages were predominantly T3 and T4 (158/188, 84%) and most patients had lymph node metastases (144/188, 77%) at diagnosis. Only 22 patients were female, 166 were male, the median age of patients was 57 years (range 34 to 76 years). Patients were randomized to one of the following three treatment options: conventional fractionation (CF) consisting of 70 Gy in 35 fractions over 7 weeks (65 patients) or continuous hyperfractionated accelerated radiation therapy (V-CHART; 62 patients) or continuous hyperfractionated accelerated radiation therapy with 20 mg/sqm MMC on day 5 (V-CHART + MMC; 61 patients). By the accelerated regimens, the total dose of 55.3 Gy was delivered within 17 consecutive days, by 33 fractions. On day 1, a single dose of 2.5 Gy was given, from day 2 to 17 a dose of 1.65 Gy was delivered twice: the interfraction interval was 6 hours or more.
Mucositis was very intense after accelerated therapy, most patients experiencing a grade III/IV reaction. The mucosal reaction did not differ whether MMC was administered or not. Patients treated by accelerated fractionation experienced a confluent mucosal reaction 12-14 days following start of therapy and recovered (no reaction) within 6 weeks. The skin reaction was not considered different in the three treatment groups. Those patients treated with additional chemotherapy experienced a grade III/IV hematologic toxicity in 12/61 patients. Initial complete response (CR) was recorded in 43% following CF, 58% after V-CHART, and 67% after V-CHART + MMC, respectively (p < 0.05). Actuarial survival (Kaplan-Meier) was significantly improved in the combined treated patients. Local tumor control was 28%, 32%, and 56% following CF, V-CHART, and V-CHART + MMC, respectively (p < 0.05).
We conclude that our continuous hyperfractionated accelerated radiation therapy regimen is equal to conventional fractionation, suggesting that by shortening the overall treatment time from 7 weeks to 17 days a reduction in dose from 70 Gy to 55.3 Gy is possible, with maintenance of local tumor control rates. The administration of MMC to the accelerated regimen is tolerable and improves the outcome for patients significantly.
评估丝裂霉素C对加速超分割放射治疗的效果。目的是在经组织学证实的头颈部鳞状细胞癌中,测试采用常规分割方式、使用或不使用丝裂霉素C(MMC)的极短疗程方案。
1990年10月至1996年12月,188例患者进入试验。肿瘤分别起源于口腔54例、口咽82例、喉20例和下咽32例。患者分期主要为T3和T4期(158/188,84%),大多数患者在诊断时已有淋巴结转移(144/188,77%)。仅22例为女性,166例为男性,患者中位年龄为57岁(范围34至76岁)。患者被随机分为以下三种治疗方案之一:常规分割(CF),7周内分35次给予70 Gy(65例患者);连续超分割加速放射治疗(V-CHART;62例患者);或在第5天给予20 mg/m²MMC的连续超分割加速放射治疗(V-CHART + MMC;61例患者)。通过加速方案,在连续17天内分33次给予55.3 Gy的总剂量。第1天给予单次剂量2.5 Gy,从第2天至第17天,每天给予1.65 Gy,分两次给予:两次照射间隔为6小时或更长时间。
加速治疗后黏膜炎非常严重,大多数患者出现III/IV级反应。无论是否给予MMC,黏膜反应无差异。接受加速分割治疗的患者在治疗开始后12 - 14天出现融合性黏膜反应,并在6周内恢复(无反应)。三个治疗组的皮肤反应无差异。接受额外化疗的患者中有12/61出现III/IV级血液学毒性。CF组、V-CHART组和V-CHART + MMC组的初始完全缓解(CR)率分别为43%、58%和67%(p < 0.05)。联合治疗患者的精算生存率(Kaplan-Meier法)显著提高。CF组、V-CHART组和V-CHART + MMC组的局部肿瘤控制率分别为28%、32%和56%(p < 0.05)。
我们得出结论,我们的连续超分割加速放射治疗方案与常规分割相当,这表明通过将总治疗时间从7周缩短至17天,有可能将剂量从70 Gy降至55.3 Gy,同时维持局部肿瘤控制率。在加速方案中给予MMC是可耐受的,并且显著改善了患者的治疗结果。