Weber M, Wirtz D, Jaeschke C, Niethard F U
Orthopädische Universitätsklinik, RWTH Aachen.
Z Orthop Ihre Grenzgeb. 1998 Nov-Dec;136(6):525-33. doi: 10.1055/s-2008-1045181.
The aim of this long-term study was to evaluate whether the Lance acetabuloplasty for congenital dysplasia of the hip causes a growth disturbance of the acetabular roof during or after puberty.
71 hips of 58 patients were followed clinically and radiologically over a maximum time of 16 years after the operative procedure of a Lance acetabuloplasty. The average age of the patients at the time of operation was 2.8 years (1-6 years). In order to assess the growth of the acetabulum in the early and long-term postoperative phase quantitative parameters (acetabular index of Hilgenreiner, CE angle of Wiberg, ACM angle of Idelberger) as well as qualitative parameters (disturbance of the ossification of the acetabulum and the femoral head) were determined in standardized X-rays of the pelvis, done routinely 6 months, 3 years, 5 years, 8 years and at an average of 11 years as the last follow-up examination after the operation. The assessment of these metrical parameters were carried out in accordance to the classification of the study-group "hip dysplasia" of the DGOT (normal--slight pathological--serious pathological) respecting the different age-groups and degrees of dysplasia.
Although in the early postoperative phase the acetabular roof showed a positive development (65% of the CE angles could be considered normal 3 years after operation), the further growth of the acetabulum was disturbed in the period of puberty (8 years after operation only 33% of the CE angles could be considered normal, 51% were extremely pathological). And also in the last X-ray control after an average follow-up time of 11 years a significant retardation of the acetabular roof was seen in 51% of all cases.
The Lance acetabuloplasty seems to damage the Ossa acetabuli, which are as centers of ossification the essential anatomic structures for the growth of the acetabular rim in adolescence.
Other procedures such as the Salter osteotomy are to be preferred for the therapy of hip dysplasia.
这项长期研究的目的是评估兰斯髋臼成形术治疗先天性髋关节发育不良是否会在青春期期间或之后导致髋臼顶生长紊乱。
对58例患者的71个髋关节在兰斯髋臼成形术手术后进行了最长16年的临床和放射学随访。患者手术时的平均年龄为2.8岁(1 - 6岁)。为了评估术后早期和长期髋臼的生长情况,在骨盆的标准化X线片上确定了定量参数(希尔根赖纳髋臼指数、维伯格CE角、伊德尔贝格ACM角)以及定性参数(髋臼和股骨头的骨化紊乱),这些X线片在术后6个月、3年、5年、8年以及平均11年作为最后一次随访检查时常规拍摄。这些测量参数的评估是根据德国骨科与创伤外科学会(DGOT)“髋关节发育不良”研究组的分类(正常 - 轻度病理 - 严重病理)进行的,同时考虑了不同的年龄组和发育不良程度。
尽管术后早期髋臼顶显示出积极的发育情况(术后3年65%的CE角可视为正常),但在青春期髋臼的进一步生长受到了干扰(术后8年只有33%的CE角可视为正常,51%为极度病理状态)。而且在平均随访11年的最后一次X线检查中,51%的所有病例都出现了髋臼顶明显的发育迟缓。
兰斯髋臼成形术似乎损害了髋臼骨,而髋臼骨作为骨化中心是青春期髋臼边缘生长的重要解剖结构。
对于髋关节发育不良的治疗,应优先选择其他手术方法,如索尔特截骨术。