Kapfhammer H P, Dobmeier P, Mayer C, Rothenhäusler H B
Psychiatrische Klinik, LMU München.
Psychother Psychosom Med Psychol. 1998 Dec;48(12):463-74.
Conversion syndromes are frequent among medically unexplained somatic symptoms in neurology. A careful differential diagnosis must be carried out in a psychiatric consultation service. In a prospective study lasting for over four years 169 patients with pseudoneurological signs of conversion were included. From a clinical point of view the following conversion syndromes were presented: astasia/abasia: 27.2%, paresis/plegia: 24.3%, aphonia: 1.8%, hyp-/anaesthesia: 21.9%, blindness: 5.3%, non-epileptic seizures: 19.5%. According to the diagnostic criteria of DSM-III-R three subgroups were differentiated: conversion disorder (n = 132), somatisation disorder (n = 28), factitious disorder (n = 9). Intermittent courses of illness were prevailing in conversion disorder, whereas chronic courses predominated in the other two subgroups. High rates of psychiatric comorbidity were typical signs of somatisation disorder. Frequent autodestructive motives (suicidality, deliberate and covert self-harm, chronic pain, high rate of operations) in illness behaviour had to be registered in somatisation and factitious disorder. Both subgroups were characterised by frequent traumatic events during early development. Important socio-economic aspects of illness behaviour above all in somatisation and factitious disorder were underlined. The results are discussed in terms of psychiatric differential diagnosis and psychiatric comorbidity, psychodynamic evaluation, illness behaviour and therapeutic options in a C/L-service.
转换综合征在神经病学中那些无法用医学解释的躯体症状中很常见。在精神科会诊服务中必须进行仔细的鉴别诊断。在一项持续四年多的前瞻性研究中,纳入了169例有转换性假性神经体征的患者。从临床角度来看,出现了以下转换综合征:起立不能/步行不能:27.2%,轻瘫/瘫痪:24.3%,失音:1.8%,感觉减退/感觉缺失:21.9%,失明:5.3%,非癫痫性发作:19.5%。根据《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第三版修订本(DSM-III-R)的诊断标准,区分出三个亚组:转换障碍(n = 132)、躯体化障碍(n = 28)、做作性障碍(n = 9)。转换障碍中疾病病程多为间歇性,而在其他两个亚组中慢性病程占主导。高比例的精神科共病是躯体化障碍的典型特征。在躯体化障碍和做作性障碍中,疾病行为中频繁出现的自我毁灭动机(自杀倾向、故意和隐蔽的自我伤害、慢性疼痛、高手术率)必须予以记录。这两个亚组的特点是在早期发育过程中频繁发生创伤性事件。强调了疾病行为的重要社会经济方面,尤其是在躯体化障碍和做作性障碍中。从精神科鉴别诊断和精神科共病、心理动力学评估、疾病行为以及临床/咨询服务中的治疗选择等方面对结果进行了讨论。