Portenoy R K, Payne R, Coluzzi P, Raschko J W, Lyss A, Busch M A, Frigerio V, Ingham J, Loseth D B, Nordbrock E, Rhiner M
Pain and Palliative Care Service, Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, USA.
Pain. 1999 Feb;79(2-3):303-12. doi: 10.1016/s0304-3959(98)00179-1.
Oral transmucosal fentanyl citrate (OTFC) is a novel opioid formulation in which the potent synthetic mu-agonist fentanyl is embedded in a sweetened matrix that is dissolved in the mouth. It is undergoing investigation as a treatment for cancer-related breakthrough pain, a prevalent phenomenon defined as a transitory flare of moderate to severe pain that interrupts otherwise controlled persistent pain. There have been no controlled trials of other treatments for this condition. To evaluate the safety and efficacy of ascending doses of OTFC, a novel controlled dose titration methodology was developed that applied blinding and randomization procedures to the evaluation of recurrent pains in the home environment. The study was a multicenter, randomized, double-blind dose titration study in ambulatory cancer patients. The sample comprised adult patients receiving a scheduled oral opioid regimen equivalent to 60-1000 mg oral morphine per day, who were experiencing at least one episode per day of breakthrough pain and had achieved at least partial relief of this pain by use of an oral opioid rescue dose. After collection of 2 days of baseline data concerning the efficacy of the usual rescue drug, patients were randomly treated with either 200 or 400 microg OTFC unit doses in double-blind fashion. Up to two breakthrough pains each day could be treated with up to four OTFC unit doses per pain. OTFC in unit doses containing 200, 400, 600, 800, 1200 or 1600 microg of fentanyl citrate were available for the study. The unit dose was titrated upward in steps until the patient had 2 consecutive days on which breakthrough pain could be treated with the single unit dose, titration was ineffective at a 1600 microg unit dose, or 20 days elapsed. To maintain the double-blind, orders to titrate up were ignored one-third of the time according to a pre-defined randomization schedule accessible only to an unblinded study pharmacist. Main outcome measures included, numeric or categorical measures of pain intensity, pain relief, and global assessment of drug performance. Dose response relationships were found suggesting that the methodology was sensitive to opioid effects. Seventy-four percent of patients were successfully titrated. There was no relationship between the total daily dose of the fixed schedule opioid regimen and the dose of OTFC required to manage the breakthrough pain. Although the study was not designed to provide a definitive comparison between OTFC and the usual rescue drug, exploratory analyses found that OTFC provided significantly greater analgesic effect at 15, 30 and 60 min, and a more rapid onset of effect, than the usual rescue drug. Adverse effects of the OTFC were typically opioid-related, specifically somnolence, nausea and dizziness. Very few adverse events were severe or serious. This study demonstrated the feasibility of controlled trial methodology in studies of breakthrough pain. OTFC appears to be a safe and effective therapy for breakthrough pain, and dose titration can usually identify a unit dose capable of providing adequate analgesia. If the lack of a relationship between the effective OTFC dose and fixed schedule opioid regimen is confirmed, dose titration may be needed in the clinical use of this formulation. Further investigation of OTFC as a specific treatment for breakthrough pain is warranted.
口腔黏膜芬太尼枸橼酸盐(OTFC)是一种新型阿片类药物制剂,强效合成μ激动剂芬太尼被嵌入一种甜味基质中,可在口腔中溶解。它正在作为癌症相关突破性疼痛的一种治疗方法进行研究,突破性疼痛是一种普遍现象,被定义为中度至重度疼痛的短暂发作,打断原本得到控制的持续性疼痛。目前尚无针对这种情况的其他治疗方法的对照试验。为了评估递增剂量OTFC的安全性和有效性,开发了一种新型的对照剂量滴定方法,该方法在家庭环境中对复发性疼痛的评估应用了盲法和随机化程序。这项研究是一项针对门诊癌症患者的多中心、随机、双盲剂量滴定研究。样本包括成年患者,他们接受相当于每天口服60 - 1000毫克口服吗啡的常规口服阿片类药物治疗方案,每天至少经历一次突破性疼痛,并且通过使用口服阿片类药物解救剂量至少部分缓解了这种疼痛。在收集了2天关于常用解救药物疗效的基线数据后,患者以双盲方式随机接受200或400微克OTFC单位剂量治疗。每天最多两次突破性疼痛,每次疼痛最多可用四个OTFC单位剂量治疗。研究中提供了含200、400、600、800、1200或1600微克枸橼酸芬太尼的单位剂量OTFC。单位剂量逐步向上滴定,直到患者连续2天能用单单位剂量治疗突破性疼痛、滴定至1600微克单位剂量无效或经过20天。为维持双盲,根据仅未设盲的研究药剂师可获取的预定义随机化方案,三分之一的时间忽略向上滴定的指令。主要结局指标包括疼痛强度、疼痛缓解以及药物性能的整体评估的数字或分类指标。发现了剂量反应关系,表明该方法对阿片类药物效应敏感。74%的患者成功滴定。固定方案阿片类药物治疗方案的每日总剂量与控制突破性疼痛所需的OTFC剂量之间没有关系。尽管该研究并非旨在对OTFC与常用解救药物进行明确比较,但探索性分析发现,OTFC在15、30和60分钟时提供的镇痛效果明显优于常用解救药物,且起效更快。OTFC的不良反应通常与阿片类药物相关,特别是嗜睡、恶心和头晕。很少有不良事件严重或危急。这项研究证明了在突破性疼痛研究中对照试验方法的可行性。OTFC似乎是一种安全有效的突破性疼痛治疗方法,剂量滴定通常可以确定能够提供充分镇痛的单位剂量。如果有效OTFC剂量与固定方案阿片类药物治疗方案之间缺乏关系得到证实,在该制剂的临床使用中可能需要进行剂量滴定。有必要进一步研究OTFC作为突破性疼痛的特异性治疗方法。