Becquemin J P, Allaire E, Qvarfordt P, Desgranges P, Kobeiter H, Melliére D
Department of Vascular Surgery, and the Département d'Imagerie Médicale, Henri Mondor Hospital, Creteil, France.
J Vasc Surg. 1999 Mar;29(3):422-9. doi: 10.1016/s0741-5214(99)70270-3.
The safety of iliac angioplasty and selective stenting performed in the operating room by vascular surgeons was evaluated, and the short- and long-term results were assessed by means of serial duplex scanning.
Between 1989 and 1996, 281 iliac stenotic or occlusive lesions in 235 consecutive patients with chronic limb ischemia were treated by means of percutaneous transluminal angioplasty (PTA) alone (n = 214) or PTA with stent (n = 67, 23.8%). There were 260 primary lesions and 21 restenosis after a first PTA, which were analyzed separately. Stents were implanted in selected cases, either primarily in totally occluded arteries or after suboptimum results of PTA (ie, residual stenosis or a dissection). Data were collected prospectively and analyzed retrospectively. Results were reported in an intention-to-treat basis. Clinical results and patency were evaluated by means of symptom assessment, ankle brachial pressure index, and duplex scanning at discharge and 1, 3, 6, and every 12 months after angioplasty. To identify factors that may affect outcome, 12 clinical and radiological variables, including the four categories of lesions defined by the Standards of Practice Committee of the Society of Cardiovascular and Interventional Radiology, were analyzed separately. The statistical significances of life-table analysis of patency were determined by means of the log-rank test.
There were no postoperative deaths or amputations. Local, general, and vascular complications occurred in 2.1%, 1.3% and 4.7% of cases, respectively (total, 8.1%). The mean follow-up period was 29.6 months. The cumulative patency rates +/- SE of the 260 PTAs (including 55 PTAs plus stents) were 92.9% +/- 1.5% at 1 month, 86. 5% +/- 1.7% at 1 year, 81.2% +/- 2.3% at 2 years, 78.8% +/- 2.9% at 3 years, and 75.4% +/- 3.5% at 5 and 6 years. The two-year patency rate of 21 redo PTAs (including 11 PTAs plus stents) was 79.1% +/- 18.2%. Of 12 predictable variables studied in the first PTA group, only the category of the lesion was predictive of long-term patency. The two-year patency rate was 84% +/- 3% for 199 category 1 lesions and 69.7% +/- 6.5% for 61 category 2, 3, and 4 lesions together (P =. 02). There was no difference of patency in the stented and nonstented group.
Iliac PTA alone or with the use of a stent (in cases of occlusion and/or suboptimal results of PTA) offers an excellent long-term patency rate. Categorization of lesions remains useful in predicting long-term outcome. PTA can be performed safely by vascular surgeons in the operating room and should be considered to be the primary treatment for localized iliac occlusive disease.
评估血管外科医生在手术室进行髂血管成形术和选择性支架置入术的安全性,并通过系列双功扫描评估其短期和长期结果。
1989年至1996年间,对235例连续性慢性肢体缺血患者的281处髂血管狭窄或闭塞性病变采用单纯经皮腔内血管成形术(PTA)(n = 214)或PTA联合支架置入术(n = 67,23.8%)进行治疗。其中有260处原发性病变和21处首次PTA术后再狭窄,分别进行分析。在选定病例中植入支架,主要用于完全闭塞动脉或PTA效果欠佳(即残余狭窄或夹层)的情况。数据前瞻性收集并回顾性分析。结果按意向性分析报告。通过症状评估、踝肱压力指数以及血管成形术后出院时、术后1、3、6个月及此后每12个月的双功扫描评估临床结果和通畅情况。为确定可能影响结果的因素,对12项临床和放射学变量进行单独分析,包括心血管和介入放射学会实践标准委员会定义的四类病变。通过对数秩检验确定通畅情况生存分析表的统计学意义。
无术后死亡或截肢病例。局部、全身和血管并发症发生率分别为2.1%、1.3%和4.7%(总计8.1%)。平均随访期为29.6个月。260次PTA(包括55次PTA联合支架置入)的累积通畅率±标准误在1个月时为92.9%±1.5%,1年时为86.5%±1.7%,2年时为81.2%±2.3%,3年时为78.8%±2.9%,5年和6年时为75.4%±3.5%。21次再次PTA(包括11次PTA联合支架置入)的两年通畅率为79.1%±18.2%。在首次PTA组研究的12项可预测变量中,仅病变类别可预测长期通畅情况。199处1类病变的两年通畅率为84%±3%,61处2、3和4类病变合计的两年通畅率为69.7%±6.5%(P = 0.02)。支架置入组和非支架置入组的通畅情况无差异。
单纯髂血管PTA或联合使用支架(用于闭塞和/或PTA效果欠佳的情况)可提供出色的长期通畅率。病变分类在预测长期结果方面仍然有用。血管外科医生可在手术室安全地进行PTA,应将其视为局限性髂血管闭塞性疾病的主要治疗方法。