López Alvarez M B, Hawkins F, Rigopoulou D, Martínez G, Jodar E, Estenoz J, Ortuño B, Arnaiz F
Centro de Atención Primaria Las Calesas, Madrid.
Med Clin (Barc). 1999 Jan 30;112(3):85-9.
It is controversial if the long-term treatment with thyroid hormone given at substitutive or suppressive doses has a negative effect on bone metabolism. In previous reports the lack of ultrasensitive TSH assays and densitometers with adequate precision, and the heterogeneity of the patients analyzed could explain these discordant results.
We have assessed bone mineral density (BMD) in 43 premenopausal and 53 postmenopausal women, who underwent near total thyroidectomy and I-131 ablation due to differentiated thyroid cancer, that have been followed up (mean duration, 75.5 [43] months) with suppressive thyroid hormone treatment (mean dose, 170 [42] micrograms) in our hospital. Patients with history of hyperthyroidism were excluded. Lumbar BMD (L2-L4) and BMD in three different sites of hip were measured (dual X-ray densitometry) to determine the contribution of several clinical and risk factors associated with thyroid hormone therapy given to BMD.
We have not found significant decrease in BMD at spine or hip when patients were compared with healthy, age and sex matched. Age (inverse correlation) and weight (direct correlation) were the variables mostly influencing BMD). Histologic type of thyroid neoplasia, doses of thyroid hormones, thyroid hormone levels and duration of follow-up, were not associated with changes in BMD. A decrease in calcium intake in postmenopausal and less physical activity in premenopausal women were related with a decreased lumbar BMD.
During long-term treatment of female patients with thyroid hormones, other risk factors should be studied in order to prevent possible loss of bone mass.
给予替代或抑制剂量的甲状腺激素进行长期治疗是否会对骨代谢产生负面影响存在争议。在以往的报告中,缺乏超灵敏促甲状腺激素检测方法和精度足够的骨密度仪,以及所分析患者的异质性可能解释了这些不一致的结果。
我们评估了43名绝经前和53名绝经后女性的骨矿物质密度(BMD),这些女性因分化型甲状腺癌接受了近全甲状腺切除术和I-131消融术,并在我院接受了抑制性甲状腺激素治疗(平均剂量为170[42]微克)的随访(平均持续时间为75.5[43]个月)。排除有甲状腺功能亢进病史的患者。测量腰椎BMD(L2-L4)和髋部三个不同部位的BMD(双能X线骨密度测定法),以确定与给予甲状腺激素治疗相关的几种临床和风险因素对BMD的影响。
与年龄、性别匹配的健康人相比,我们未发现患者的脊柱或髋部BMD有显著下降。年龄(负相关)和体重(正相关)是对BMD影响最大的变量。甲状腺肿瘤的组织学类型、甲状腺激素剂量、甲状腺激素水平和随访时间与BMD的变化无关。绝经后女性钙摄入量减少和绝经前女性体力活动减少与腰椎BMD降低有关。
在对女性患者进行甲状腺激素长期治疗期间,应研究其他风险因素,以预防可能的骨质流失。