Rambeaud J J
Department of Urology, University Hospital of Grenoble, France.
Eur Urol. 1999;35 Suppl 1:32-6.
Intermittent hormonal treatment of prostate cancer was first developed based upon experimental study results. Using the Shionogi mouse breast cancer model, it was shown that the tumor grows rapidly in the presence of androgens, then undergoes apoptotic regression when androgens are removed. This apoptotic potential can be reinduced several times by cyclic replacement and withdrawal of androgens. These results led to the concept being evaluated in clinical trials.
In most of the clinical studies a protocol is used in which the patient receives 36 weeks of androgen deprivation. For those patients whose prostate-specific antigen (PSA) drops to less than 4 ng/ml within 32 weeks of therapy, the androgen withdrawal is stopped at 36 weeks, and not reintroduced until PSA increases to 20 ng/ml. This cycle is then repeated until the patient's tumor becomes hormone-sensitive.
Akakura et al. in 1993, reported on 7 patients who had a total of 12 episodes off-hormone therapy after achieving PSA complex remission, with further response after each re-exposure. Bruchovsky et al. in 1997, reported on 47 patients who entered a study of intermittent hormone therapy to evaluate the effect of cyclic withdrawal and replacement therapy in 14 D2, 10 D, 19 C, 2 B2, 2 A2 patients. Treatment was initiated with combined androgen blockade and continued for at least 6 months until a serum PSA nadir was observed. The first two treatment cycles lasted 73 and 75 weeks, with a mean time-off therapy of 30 and 33 weeks and an overall mean percentage time-off therapy of 41 and 45%. Serum testosterone returned to the normal range within 8 weeks (range: 1-26 weeks) of stopping treatment. The off-treatment period in both cycles was associated with an improvement in sense of well-being, and the recovery of libido and potency in the men who reported normal or near-normal sexual function before the start of therapy. In 7 patients with stage D2 disease, the cancer progressed to an androgen-independent state. The mean and median times to progression were 128 and 108 weeks. Seven patients died, one from a non-cancer-related illness, with mean and median overall survival times of 210 and 166 weeks.
These studies demonstrated that the androgen-dependent state of prostate cancer can be maintained during a course of intermittent androgen suppression, supporting the possibility of multiple apoptotic regressions under well-regulated conditions. Oliver et al. in 1997, conducted a retrospective study of 20 patients and concluded that intermittent androgen deprivation reduced induction of hormone-resistant prostate cancer, with no acute or major risk associated with the use of intermittent androgen suppression. More clinical studies are required to clarify the indication for intermittent hormone therapy and evaluate improvement in quality of life and survival. In the future, approaches to the improvement of therapeutic apoptosis could include intermittent hormone therapy, associated with additive cytotoxic therapeutic strategies.
前列腺癌的间歇性激素治疗最初是基于实验研究结果而开发的。利用日本住友制药公司的小鼠乳腺癌模型,研究表明肿瘤在雄激素存在的情况下迅速生长,而当去除雄激素时则会发生凋亡性消退。通过雄激素的周期性替代和撤药,这种凋亡潜能可以被多次重新诱导。这些结果促使这一概念在临床试验中得到评估。
在大多数临床研究中,采用的方案是患者接受36周的雄激素剥夺治疗。对于那些在治疗32周内前列腺特异性抗原(PSA)降至4 ng/ml以下的患者,雄激素撤药在36周时停止,直到PSA升高至20 ng/ml才重新引入。然后重复这个周期,直到患者的肿瘤对激素敏感。
赤仓等人在1993年报告了7例患者,这些患者在PSA完全缓解后总共经历了12次激素停药期,每次重新暴露后都有进一步反应。布鲁乔夫斯基等人在1997年报告了47例进入间歇性激素治疗研究的患者,以评估14例D2期、10例D期、19例C期、2例B2期、2例A2期患者的周期性撤药和替代治疗效果。治疗开始时采用联合雄激素阻断,并持续至少6个月,直到观察到血清PSA最低点。前两个治疗周期分别持续73周和75周,平均停药时间分别为30周和33周,总体平均停药时间百分比分别为41%和45%。停止治疗后8周内(范围:1 - 26周)血清睾酮恢复到正常范围。两个周期中的停药期都与幸福感的改善以及治疗开始前报告性功能正常或接近正常的男性的性欲和性功能恢复有关。在7例D2期疾病患者中,癌症进展为雄激素非依赖状态。进展的平均和中位时间分别为128周和108周。7例患者死亡,1例死于与癌症无关的疾病,总体平均和中位生存时间分别为210周和166周。
这些研究表明,在间歇性雄激素抑制过程中可以维持前列腺癌的雄激素依赖状态,支持在良好调控的条件下进行多次凋亡性消退的可能性。奥利弗等人在1997年对20例患者进行了回顾性研究,得出结论:间歇性雄激素剥夺减少了激素抵抗性前列腺癌的诱导,使用间歇性雄激素抑制没有急性或重大风险。需要更多的临床研究来明确间歇性激素治疗的适应症,并评估生活质量和生存率的改善情况。未来,改善治疗性凋亡的方法可能包括间歇性激素治疗,并结合附加的细胞毒性治疗策略。