Joseph D M
Institute for Medical Conflict Management, Tucson, AZ 85749, USA.
Med Group Manage J. 1995 Jul-Aug;42(4):86-90, 92.
Conflict is a growth industry, particularly in an increasingly complex health care system. Litigation is the most common, and most costly, method of settling health care disputes. Highly adversarial, the process of litigation often generates as much, if not more, hostility than the original dispute. In addition, satisfaction with the outcome is very low. The challenge that has arisen is to manage the conflicts so that the underlying needs and interests of all the parties can best be met. Often the techniques and processes of alternative dispute resolution (ADR) can be successfully used in resolving these sorts of conflicts quickly, cheaply and with greater satisfaction for all parties. Various applications of ADR are currently being used or tested in a variety of health care disputes in the United States and Canada. Tremendous success has been achieved in mediating medical malpractice claims, medical staff disputes, economic credentialing conflicts, insurer relations issues and denial of coverage disputes. Professional relations and departmental staff disputes, partnership and employee conflicts, and organizational disputes within clinics, HMOs and large group practices have all been found particularly amenable to ADR. These are all situations in which everyone benefits from quick, non-hostile resolutions and on-going relationships can continue.
冲突是一个不断发展的领域,尤其是在日益复杂的医疗保健系统中。诉讼是解决医疗保健纠纷最常见且成本最高的方式。诉讼过程极具对抗性,往往会引发与最初纠纷一样多(甚至更多)的敌意。此外,对诉讼结果的满意度非常低。由此产生的挑战是管理冲突,以便最好地满足所有各方的潜在需求和利益。通常,替代性纠纷解决方式(ADR)的技巧和流程能够成功用于快速、低成本地解决这类冲突,并让所有各方都更满意。目前,ADR的各种应用正在美国和加拿大的各类医疗保健纠纷中得到使用或测试。在调解医疗事故索赔、医务人员纠纷、经济资格认证冲突、保险公司关系问题以及保险范围拒绝纠纷方面已取得巨大成功。专业关系和部门员工纠纷、合伙关系和员工冲突,以及诊所、健康维护组织(HMO)和大型团体医疗机构内部的组织纠纷,都已发现特别适合采用ADR。在所有这些情况下,各方都能从快速、非对抗性的解决方案中受益,并且持续的关系能够得以维系。