Sullivan G, Spritzer K
University of Arkansas for Medical Science, Little Rock 72204, USA.
J Rural Health. 1997 Winter;13(1):6-13. doi: 10.1111/j.1748-0361.1997.tb00829.x.
In the context of restrictive admissions policies at public inpatient facilities, rates of arrest and incarceration of persons with serious mental illness (SMI) have been increasing, leading to the perception that SMI persons are being unduly "criminalized." This paper describes the characteristics of persons with SMI (N = 177) in Mississippi who have been (1) jailed without charges while awaiting a hospital bed and (2) jailed for a criminal offense. Seventy-five percent (N = 132) of the 177 subjects had been held in local jails awaiting state hospital admission at least once in their lives, most for more than five days. Fifteen percent (N = 26) had contact with the police for a criminal offense in the past year. Rural residence markedly increased the risk for waiting in jail (OR = 4.24) but was not related to committing a criminal offense. Protective factors for any type of criminal justice contact were female gender, caucasian ethnicity, better compliance with medication regimes, and nonrural residence. The phenomenon of rural criminalization, i.e., waiting in jail without criminal charges, differs qualitatively from the criminalization that occurs in urban areas and may require a different solution. To avoid criminalization of SMI persons in rural areas, public mental health systems must develop effective crisis interventions in the community or work with local law enforcement officials and medical and mental health facilities to create more immediate access to acute inpatient care.
在公立住院设施实行限制性收治政策的背景下,严重精神疾病(SMI)患者的逮捕率和监禁率不断上升,导致人们认为SMI患者被过度“刑事化”。本文描述了密西西比州177名SMI患者的特征,这些患者(1)在等待医院床位时未经指控被监禁,以及(2)因刑事犯罪被监禁。177名受试者中有75%(N = 132)一生中至少有一次被关押在当地监狱等待州立医院收治,大多数人被关押超过五天。15%(N = 26)在过去一年中因刑事犯罪与警方有过接触。农村居民在监狱等待的风险显著增加(OR = 4.24),但与刑事犯罪无关。任何类型刑事司法接触的保护因素包括女性、白种人、更好地遵守药物治疗方案以及非农村居住。农村刑事化现象,即在没有刑事指控的情况下在监狱等待,在性质上与城市地区发生的刑事化不同,可能需要不同的解决方案。为避免农村地区SMI患者被刑事化,公共精神卫生系统必须在社区开展有效的危机干预,或与当地执法官员以及医疗和精神卫生设施合作,以创造更直接的急性住院治疗途径。