Crowley J R, Tillman M H, Fischer P M
Department of Medical Technology, Medical College of Georgia, Augusta.
Clin Lab Sci. 1992 Nov-Dec;5(6):349-53.
The effectiveness of systematically designed print-based materials in teaching (a) knowledge of laboratory tests and (b) laboratory test skills to laboratory staff in small office practices was measured. Self-guided packets on Gram stain performance and interpretation, rapid streptococcal testing, and vaginal wet preparations were developed by a multidisciplinary team. A total of 21 staff members (14 treatment, 7 control) in 12 family practice offices with three or fewer physicians participated in the study. A posttest-only control group design was used to determine the effects of using the self-guided instructional packets. The treatment group, in relation to the control, scored significantly higher on tests of knowledge for all packets, demonstrated no difference in scores for Gram stain or streptococcal test skills, and scored significantly higher for identification of elements in photographs of vaginal wet preparations. Results affirmed both the usefulness and limitations of print-based instruction for knowledge level outcomes. For developing laboratory test skills additional forms of instruction are needed.
评估了系统设计的纸质材料在向小型诊所的实验室工作人员传授(a)实验室检测知识和(b)实验室检测技能方面的有效性。一个多学科团队开发了关于革兰氏染色操作与解读、快速链球菌检测以及阴道湿片检查的自助式资料包。12个医师人数为三人或更少的家庭诊所共有21名工作人员参与了研究(14人接受治疗,7人作为对照)。采用仅在测试后进行的对照组设计来确定使用自助式教学资料包的效果。与对照组相比,治疗组在所有资料包的知识测试中得分显著更高,在革兰氏染色或链球菌检测技能的得分上没有差异,而在阴道湿片照片中元素识别方面得分显著更高。结果证实了纸质教学对于知识水平成果的有用性和局限性。对于培养实验室检测技能,还需要其他形式的教学。