Mark A, Elliott R
Middlesex University Business School, London, UK.
Int J Health Plann Manage. 1997 Oct-Dec;12(4):297-314. doi: 10.1002/(SICI)1099-1751(199710/12)12:4<297::AID-HPM493>3.0.CO;2-X.
This article considers demarketing as a strategy to manage dysfunctional demand in the UK NHS. Demarketing seeks to persuade customers not to use a service which is provided. It appears in all four modes in the NHS as general, selective, ostensible and unintentional demarketing with an emphasis on supply-side applications. It is proposed that, as a demand-side strategy, it would allow purchasers of health care on behalf of communities, to discern values, attitudes and beliefs which predicate current behaviour through the use of the Theory of Planned Behaviour; and, subsequently, to develop appropriate demarketing alternatives to change these behaviours where they are dysfunctional for both consumer and provider. This approach is proposed for the significant behavioural changes required to manage the increases in the use of emergency services: in particular, general practitioner night calls, which are already developing evidence-based demand management strategies. Such alternative strategies need to demonstrate their acceptability to consumers rather than just the professionals. Such demand management strategies would be made more acceptable as they are drawn from both consumer and normative attitudes, values and beliefs. In this way demarketing could demonstrably provide a framework for intervention, collaboration, decentralization, explicitness and an ethical foundation to the key problem of demand management in health care.
本文将反营销视为英国国民医疗服务体系(NHS)中管理功能失调性需求的一种策略。反营销旨在劝说顾客不要使用已提供的服务。在NHS中,它以一般反营销、选择性反营销、表面反营销和无意反营销这四种模式出现,重点在于供应方的应用。有人提出,作为一种需求方策略,它将使代表社区的医疗保健购买者能够通过运用计划行为理论来辨别那些决定当前行为的价值观、态度和信念;随后,在这些行为对消费者和提供者都产生功能失调影响时,开发合适的反营销替代方案来改变这些行为。针对管理急诊服务使用量增加所需的重大行为改变,特别是全科医生夜间出诊(目前已经在制定基于证据的需求管理策略),建议采用这种方法。此类替代策略需要向消费者而非仅仅向专业人员证明其可接受性。由于这些需求管理策略源自消费者以及规范的态度、价值观和信念,所以它们会更易被接受。通过这种方式,反营销能够切实为医疗保健需求管理这一关键问题提供一个干预、协作、权力下放、明晰性以及道德基础的框架。