Schultz E, Miller T T, Boruchov S D, Schmell E B, Toledano B
Department of Radiology, North Shore University Hospital, Manhasset, NY 11030, USA.
Radiology. 1999 Apr;211(1):237-40. doi: 10.1148/radiology.211.1.r99mr24237.
To present the imaging findings and treatment options for incomplete intertrochanteric fractures.
Among 31 patients with the magnetic resonance (MR) imaging diagnosis of incomplete intertrochanteric fracture, 30 also underwent radiography. MR and radiographic findings were compared. Note was made of fracture length and extent as depicted on the coronal and axial MR images, treatment (surgical vs conservative), and follow-up.
Correlation between radiographic and MR findings was poor. Incomplete intertrochanteric fracture was the prospective radiographic diagnosis in only one case. Fracture in 18 patients was treated surgically and in 13 was managed conservatively. In both groups, the average age of the patients and length of the fractures and the percentage of separate fractures involving the greater trochanter and crossing the midline of the femur in the axial plane were the same. Fractures crossed the midline in the coronal plane in 50% of the surgical group but in only 23% of the nonsurgical group. Average time from injury to ambulation was 2 days less in the surgical group, but no difference in functional status was found subjectively between the two groups at clinical follow-up.
Incomplete intertrochanteric fractures are a previously unrecognized subset of intertrochanteric fractures that are diagnosed unequivocally only with MR imaging.
介绍股骨转子间不完全骨折的影像学表现及治疗选择。
在31例经磁共振(MR)成像诊断为股骨转子间不完全骨折的患者中,30例还接受了X线摄影。比较MR和X线摄影的表现。记录冠状面和轴位MR图像上显示的骨折长度和范围、治疗方法(手术治疗与保守治疗)及随访情况。
X线摄影与MR表现之间的相关性较差。仅1例患者X线摄影前瞻性诊断为股骨转子间不完全骨折。18例患者接受手术治疗,13例采用保守治疗。两组患者的平均年龄、骨折长度以及累及大转子且在轴位平面上穿过股骨中线的分离骨折百分比相同。手术组50%的骨折在冠状面穿过中线,而非手术组仅23%。手术组从受伤到行走的平均时间少2天,但临床随访时两组主观功能状态无差异。
股骨转子间不完全骨折是一种以前未被认识的转子间骨折亚型,仅通过MR成像才能明确诊断。