Matsui K, Polanczyk C A, Gaspoz J M, Theres H, Kleber F X, Sobashima A, Okamatsu S, Viana J M, Ribeiro J P, Emonet S, Lee T H
Aso HealthCare Institute, Japan.
J Investig Med. 1999 Mar;47(3):134-40.
Although variability in management of cardiovascular syndromes has been demonstrated among regions, the extent to which variability exists among academic medical centers in different countries in uncertain.
This retrospective cohort study includes data on consecutive patients (n = 694) with acute myocardial infarction who were admitted to five teaching hospitals from different countries (84, Brigham and Women's Hospital, USA; 97, Iizuka Hospital, Japan; 64, Hospital de Clinicas de Porto Alegre, Brazil; 62, Universitätsklinikum Charité, Germany; and 387, Hôpital Cantonal Universitaire de Genève, Switzerland) during a one-year period. Data were collected via chart review on clinical characteristics, rates of diagnostic and therapeutic interventions, complications and mortality, length of stay, and one-year follow-up outcomes.
Patients' clinical characteristics varied among these institutions, with the lowest prevalence of antero-septal myocardial infarction at the US hospital. The US hospital had the lowest rate of use of thrombolytic therapy and did not have the highest rate for any invasive procedure. Average length of stay ranged from 7.7 +/- 4.3 days in the US hospital to 47.2 +/- 27.9 days in the Japanese hospital. There were no differences in one-year mortality among the four institutions (4% to 8%, P = 0.881) for which data were available.
In this nonrandom sample of academic medical centers, the use of aggressive therapies for acute myocardial infarction was at least as common at non-US as US hospitals. Length of stay was much shorter at the US hospital. Despite these variations in management, evidence for differences in outcomes at one year were not detected.
尽管已证明心血管综合征的管理在不同地区存在差异,但不同国家学术医疗中心之间的差异程度尚不确定。
这项回顾性队列研究纳入了连续一年期间入住来自不同国家的五家教学医院(美国布莱根妇女医院84例;日本饭冢医院97例;巴西阿雷格里港临床医院64例;德国柏林夏里特大学医院62例;瑞士日内瓦大学医院387例)的急性心肌梗死患者(n = 694)的数据。通过病历审查收集有关临床特征、诊断和治疗干预率、并发症和死亡率、住院时间以及一年随访结果的数据。
这些机构之间患者的临床特征各不相同,美国医院前间壁心肌梗死的患病率最低。美国医院溶栓治疗的使用率最低,且任何侵入性手术的使用率都不是最高的。平均住院时间从美国医院的7.7±4.3天到日本医院的47.2±27.9天不等。在有数据的四家机构中,一年死亡率没有差异(4%至8%,P = 0.881)。
在这个学术医疗中心的非随机样本中,非美国医院对急性心肌梗死采用积极治疗的情况至少与美国医院一样普遍。美国医院的住院时间要短得多。尽管管理存在这些差异,但未发现一年结局存在差异的证据。