Foster J, Jessopp L, Dale J
Department of General Practice and Primary Care, Guy's School of Medicine, London.
Br J Gen Pract. 1999 Feb;49(439):111-3.
In recent years the number of telephone consultations provided out of hours has increased. However, most general practitioners (GPs) have received little training in this area despite the specific skills needed to compensate for lack of visual information. Moreover, there has been no research exploring GPs' concerns and training needs in telephone consulting.
To assess GPs' concerns and levels of confidence in providing telephone consultations in order to inform the development of a new training course.
Prior to attending the course, GPs were surveyed by interview or self-completion questionnaire to explore their confidence in providing telephone consultations.
Thirty-eight GPs participated, and the sample was highly skewed towards females. The average age of participants was 42 years, 5 years less than the mean for GPs in the area. Low levels of confidence were reported by GPs in providing telephone consultations out of hours. A number of characteristics were common to telephone consultations described as difficult. The most important were lack of visual clues and lack of information about the patient, both of these were heightened in the out-of-hours period. Organizational factors leading to reduced confidence levels were also identified.
This study demonstrates low levels of confidence among GPs conducting telephone consultations, and highlights contributing factors. Although it is not clear how far these results can be generalized, they demonstrate the need to consider telephone consulting skills training in the context of new out-of-hours arrangements. The results have been used to develop a two-day course.
近年来,非工作时间提供的电话咨询数量有所增加。然而,尽管需要特定技能来弥补缺乏视觉信息的不足,但大多数全科医生(GP)在这方面接受的培训很少。此外,尚未有研究探讨全科医生在电话咨询中的担忧和培训需求。
评估全科医生在提供电话咨询方面的担忧和信心水平,以便为新培训课程的开发提供参考。
在参加课程之前,通过访谈或自我填写问卷对全科医生进行调查,以了解他们在提供电话咨询方面的信心。
38名全科医生参与了调查,样本严重偏向女性。参与者的平均年龄为42岁,比该地区全科医生的平均年龄小5岁。全科医生报告称,在非工作时间提供电话咨询的信心水平较低。被描述为困难的电话咨询有一些共同特征。最重要的是缺乏视觉线索和关于患者的信息,这两者在非工作时间都更为突出。还确定了导致信心水平降低的组织因素。
本研究表明,进行电话咨询的全科医生信心水平较低,并突出了相关影响因素。尽管尚不清楚这些结果能在多大程度上推广,但它们表明在新的非工作时间安排背景下需要考虑电话咨询技能培训。研究结果已被用于开发一个为期两天的课程。