Mok C C, Lau C S, Chan T M, Wong R W
Department of Medicine, Queen Mary Hospital, Pokfulam, Hong Kong.
Lupus. 1999;8(3):188-96. doi: 10.1191/096120399678847605.
The aims were to study the gender differences in clinical manifestations, disease course and organ damage in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Clinical manifestations, autoantibody profile, relapses and damage scores were obtained from 51 Chinese males with SLE and compared with 201 consecutive female SLE controls. Fifty-one males were identified among 630 SLE patients who attended our clinics, giving a male prevalence of 8% and a female to male ratio of 11.4-1. Both the male SLE patients and the female controls had similar age and SLEDAI score at disease onset. Male SLE patients had less alopecia (P = 0.03), Raynaud's phenomenon (P = 0.01) and anti-Ro (P = 0.049) during the course of the disease but none of the differences were statistically significant after correction for multiple observations. The prevalence of major organ involvement in either sex was not different. Both groups of patients had a comparable mean duration of follow-up (104 vs. 102 months, P = 0.87). Males had a significantly lower rate of relapses (total No. of flares/patient-year: 0.23 in men vs. 0.33 in women, P = 0.04), but the frequency of severe flares (No. of severe flares/patient-year in men 0.08 vs. 0.12 in women, P = 0.16) was not significantly different from the females. Male patients with positive anti-Ro had significantly less overall flares than their female counterparts who were anti-Ro positive (0.16 vs. 0.34, P = 0.006). However, the use of immunosuppressive agents for disease control in patients of both sexes was similar. 22 (43%) of the males and 78 (39%) of the females had organ damage. A higher percentage of male patients had impairment of renal function (P = 0.006) but the proportion of patients who required dialysis was not different (4% in men vs. 2% in females. P = 0.92). There was also a trend of more cardiovascular damage in the males but the difference was not statistically significant (P = 0.09). The mean SLICC/ACR scores were not significantly higher in the males than the females (0.71 vs. 0.60, P = 0.47). Males tend to differ from females in clinical manifestations, immunological profile and disease course in SLE. However, there was no gender difference in the involvement of major organs/systems. Males had less overall disease flares than the females but the rate of severe flares was not significantly lower. For patients who were anti-Ro positive, males had significantly less total number of flares/patient-year than their female counterparts. More renal impairment and cardiovascular damage was present in our male lupus patients but the overall damage scores were not significantly higher.
本研究旨在探讨系统性红斑狼疮(SLE)患者在临床表现、病程及器官损害方面的性别差异。收集了51例中国男性SLE患者的临床表现、自身抗体谱、复发情况及损害评分,并与201例连续的女性SLE对照进行比较。在630例到我院门诊就诊的SLE患者中,共识别出51例男性患者,男性患病率为8%,男女比例为11.4:1。男性SLE患者和女性对照在发病时年龄及SLE疾病活动指数(SLEDAI)评分相似。男性SLE患者在病程中脱发(P = 0.03)、雷诺现象(P = 0.01)及抗Ro抗体阳性率(P = 0.049)较低,但经多重观察校正后,这些差异均无统计学意义。两性主要器官受累的患病率无差异。两组患者的平均随访时间相当(104个月 vs. 102个月,P = 0.87)。男性患者的复发率显著较低(总发作次数/患者年:男性为0.23,女性为0.33,P = 0.04),但严重发作的频率(男性严重发作次数/患者年为0.08,女性为0.12,P = 0.16)与女性无显著差异。抗Ro抗体阳性的男性患者总体发作次数显著少于抗Ro抗体阳性的女性患者(0.16 vs. 0.34,P = 0.006)。然而,两性患者用于疾病控制的免疫抑制剂使用情况相似。22例(43%)男性和78例(39%)女性出现器官损害。男性患者肾功能损害的比例较高(P = 0.006),但需要透析的患者比例无差异(男性4%,女性2%,P = 0.92)。男性患者心血管损害也有增多趋势,但差异无统计学意义(P = 0.09)。男性的平均系统性红斑狼疮国际协作临床/美国风湿病学会(SLICC/ACR)评分并不显著高于女性(0.71 vs. 0.60,P = 0.47)。SLE男性患者在临床表现、免疫特征及病程方面与女性存在差异。然而,在主要器官/系统受累方面不存在性别差异。男性患者总体疾病发作次数少于女性,但严重发作率并未显著降低。对于抗Ro抗体阳性的患者,男性患者每年的总发作次数显著少于女性患者。我们的男性狼疮患者存在更多的肾功能损害和心血管损害,但总体损害评分并未显著升高。