Pianta R C, Longmaid K, Ferguson J E
Curry School of Education, University of Virginia, Charlottesville 22906-9051, USA.
J Clin Child Psychol. 1999 Jun;28(2):244-55. doi: 10.1207/s15374424jccp2802_11.
Investigated an attachment-based theoretical framework and classification system, introduced by Kaplan and Main (1986), for interpreting children's family drawings. This study concentrated on the psychometric properties of the system and the relation between drawings classified using this system and teacher ratings of classroom social-emotional and behavioral functioning, controlling for child age, ethnic status, intelligence, and fine motor skills. This nonclinical sample consisted of 200 kindergarten children of diverse racial and socioeconomic status (SES). Limited support for reliability of this classification system was obtained. Kappas for overall classifications of drawings (e.g., secure) exceeded .80 and mean kappa for discrete drawing features (e.g., figures with smiles) was .82. Coders' endorsement of the presence of certain discrete drawing features predicted their overall classification at 82.5% accuracy. Drawing classification was related to teacher ratings of classroom functioning independent of child age, sex, race, SES, intelligence, and fine motor skills (with p values for the multivariate effects ranging from .043-.001). Results are discussed in terms of the psychometric properties of this system for classifying children's representations of family and the limitations of family drawing techniques for young children.
研究了由卡普兰和梅因(1986年)提出的基于依恋的理论框架和分类系统,用于解读儿童的家庭绘画。本研究集中于该系统的心理测量特性,以及使用此系统分类的绘画与教师对课堂社交情感和行为功能的评分之间的关系,同时控制儿童年龄、种族地位、智力和精细运动技能。这个非临床样本由200名来自不同种族和社会经济地位(SES)的幼儿园儿童组成。对该分类系统的可靠性获得了有限的支持。绘画总体分类(如安全型)的卡帕值超过0.80,离散绘画特征(如面带微笑的人物)的平均卡帕值为0.82。编码员对某些离散绘画特征存在的认可,以82.5%的准确率预测了他们的总体分类。绘画分类与教师对课堂功能的评分相关,独立于儿童年龄、性别、种族、SES、智力和精细运动技能(多变量效应的p值范围为0.043 - 0.001)。从该系统对儿童家庭表征进行分类的心理测量特性以及幼儿家庭绘画技术的局限性方面对结果进行了讨论。