Martlew M, Connolly K J
Department of Psychology, University of Sheffield, UK.
Child Dev. 1996 Dec;67(6):2743-62.
Human figure drawings were collected from 287 schooled and unschooled children, aged between 10 and 15 years, living in a remote region of the Western Highlands Province of Papua New Guinea, an area with no tradition of graphic art. A classification and ordinal scoring system was devised which encompassed graphic productions ranging from scribbles to conventional competent human figure drawings. The effects of school experience on drawing, even brief and indirect experience, were found to be significant. All the children attending school drew only conventional human figures, but the whole range of drawings, scribbles, transitional forms, and conventional human figure drawings were found in the unschooled children's attempts. Nonrepresentational scribbles and shapes were largely produced by unschooled children living in remote villages without a school, trade store, or mission. Some children appeared to be able to draw representations of the human figure without going through a scribbling stage. The material is considered in relation to other reports on drawings produced by children from societies with little or no indigenous graphic art. The results are discussed in relation to various theories on the development of drawing and representational abilities.
从巴布亚新几内亚西部高地省一个偏远地区收集了287名10至15岁的在校和未上学儿童的人物画,该地区没有图形艺术传统。设计了一种分类和序数评分系统,该系统涵盖了从涂鸦到传统的合格人物画的图形作品。发现学校经历对绘画的影响,即使是短暂和间接的经历,也是显著的。所有上学的孩子只画传统的人物,但在未上学孩子的尝试中发现了各种类型的画,包括涂鸦、过渡形式和传统人物画。非具象的涂鸦和形状主要由生活在没有学校、商店或传教机构的偏远村庄的未上学孩子创作。一些孩子似乎能够在不经过涂鸦阶段的情况下画出人物形象。本文将这些材料与其他关于来自几乎没有或没有本土图形艺术社会的儿童所画作品的报告联系起来进行了考量。并结合关于绘画和表征能力发展的各种理论对结果进行了讨论。