Troeger C, Briese V, Müller H
Frauenklinik und Poliklinik, Universität Rostock.
Zentralbl Gynakol. 1999;121(5):233-8.
The purpose of this study was to investigate the validity of cardiotocography for the detection of cord complications.
A low-risk population of 4196 cases was selected in which cord complications have been recognized in 34.3%. Cases with cord complications and controls were paired by parity, gestational age, maternal age and mode of delivery. 25 pairs were randomly selected. 50 tracings were presented twice to 4 obstetricians in a double-blind manner. As parameters for the determination of the validity of fetal monitoring the reliability, positive (ppv) and negative predictive value (npv), sensitivity and specificity were used. Inter- and intra-observer variability were also examined.
Reliability 52%, ppv 52%, npv 52%, sensitivity 46%, specificity 58%. Interobserver variability: All 4 obstetricians agreed in 47 of 100 evaluations. The level of agreement was higher in the controls (63%) than in the cord complication group (56%). The intraobserver variability was 25%.
Cardiotocography is not useful for the detection of cord complications. The range of possibilities has not been exploited yet, even for the evaluation of the fetal state.
本研究旨在探讨胎心监护用于检测脐带并发症的有效性。
选取4196例低风险人群,其中34.3%被诊断为有脐带并发症。将有脐带并发症的病例与对照组按产次、孕周、产妇年龄及分娩方式进行配对。随机选取25对。以双盲方式向4位产科医生两次展示50份胎心监护图。采用可靠性、阳性预测值(ppv)、阴性预测值(npv)、敏感性和特异性作为判定胎儿监护有效性的参数。同时也检测了观察者间及观察者内的变异性。
可靠性52%,阳性预测值52%,阴性预测值52%,敏感性46%,特异性58%。观察者间变异性:在100次评估中,4位产科医生全部达成一致的有47次。对照组的一致率(63%)高于脐带并发症组(56%)。观察者内变异性为25%。
胎心监护对检测脐带并发症无用。即便对于评估胎儿状态而言,其可能性范围也尚未得到充分利用。