Tamura K
First Department of Internal Medicine, Fukuoka University Hospital, Japan.
Fukuoka Igaku Zasshi. 1999 Jun;90(6):279-85.
Granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF) has been used in practice in Japan since 1991, but there is still a controversy how to use it properly. It is of importance to know how Japanese physicians manage neutropenic patients with G-CSF.
The way of using G-CSF in clinical practice after chemotherapy was investigated in Fukuoka city area in Japan. Fifty physicians working at large hospitals and in charge of oncological patients participated in this study. A questionnaire regarding use of G-CSF including case studies was directly handed to each of them. All questions were made using the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) survey for use of hematopoieteic CSFs (J Clin Oncol 1996; 14: 1957) to compare the results between the 2 countries.
For primary prophylactic administration of G-CSF, 29% of the physicians "always" or "usually" used it to prevent neutropenia in the first cycle of chemotherapy, while 55% physicians used G-CSF as a secondary prophylaxis for the patients with experiences of neutropenia in the previous chemotherapy and at the start of the next cycle of cytotoxic agents. Once the patients developed neutropenia, G-CSF was "always" used for afebrile neutropenia by a half of the physicians, and even more physicians used it for febrile neutropenia. Nineteen out of 50 doctors had experiences of reimbursement troubles with the health insurance largely due to too-long use of G-CSF.
The results are generally in agreement with ASCO members' way of using CSFs, but Japanese physicians tend to use G-CSF more frequently than ASCO members in primary prophylaxis or in treatment of neutropenia.
自1991年以来,粒细胞集落刺激因子(G-CSF)已在日本临床实践中使用,但对于如何正确使用它仍存在争议。了解日本医生如何管理使用G-CSF的中性粒细胞减少患者非常重要。
在日本福冈市地区调查了化疗后临床实践中使用G-CSF的方式。五十名在大型医院工作并负责肿瘤患者的医生参与了这项研究。一份关于G-CSF使用情况包括病例研究的问卷直接分发给他们每个人。所有问题均参照美国临床肿瘤学会(ASCO)关于造血生长因子使用情况的调查问卷(《临床肿瘤学杂志》1996年;14:1957)编制,以便比较两国之间的结果。
对于G-CSF的一级预防性给药,29%的医生“总是”或“通常”在化疗的第一个周期使用它来预防中性粒细胞减少,而55%的医生将G-CSF用作对先前化疗中有中性粒细胞减少经历且在下一周期细胞毒性药物开始使用时的患者的二级预防。一旦患者出现中性粒细胞减少,一半的医生“总是”将G-CSF用于无发热性中性粒细胞减少,甚至更多医生将其用于发热性中性粒细胞减少。50名医生中有19名经历过医疗保险报销问题,主要原因是G-CSF使用时间过长。
结果总体上与ASCO成员使用生长因子的方式一致,但日本医生在一级预防或中性粒细胞减少治疗中倾向于比ASCO成员更频繁地使用G-CSF。