Fennig S, Rabinowitz J, Fennig S
Shalvata Mental Health Center, Hod Hasharon, Israel.
Psychiatr Serv. 1999 Aug;50(8):1049-52. doi: 10.1176/ps.50.8.1049.
The extent to which the legal status of a first psychiatric admission-voluntary or involuntary-predicted the legal status and number of future admissions was examined among patients with schizophrenia.
Data on all patients in Israel who had a nonforensic first admission between 1978 and 1992 and a diagnosis of schizophrenia (N=9,081) were extracted from the national psychiatric hospitalization case registry. Also obtained from the registry was information about the patients' subsequent hospitalizations through 1995, demographic data, and diagnosis. Analyses adjusted for time since first admission, age at first admission, country of origin, and religion.
The first admission of 12.9 percent of the patients was involuntary. The legal status of the first admission was not related to the number of readmissions. However, female patients whose first admission was involuntary were 4.1 times more likely to have an involuntary second admission than female patients whose first admission was voluntary; these odds were 3.4 for males. Further analysis examined the percentage of involuntary admissions among all hospitalizations of the 3,420 patients who had four or more admissions (chronic patients). Among the chronic patients who had an involuntary first admission, 41 percent of subsequent admissions were involuntary. This figure was significantly lower among the chronic patients who had a voluntary first admission-13 percent. The percentage of involuntary admissions was not related to the number of admissions.
The strong association of involuntary legal status at first admission with involuntary status at second admission and with the number of involuntary admissions over time suggests that involuntary first admission might be an important factor in assessing whether patients are likely to be readmitted involuntarily.
在精神分裂症患者中,研究首次精神病住院的法律状态(自愿或非自愿)对未来住院的法律状态及次数的预测程度。
从国家精神病住院病例登记处提取1978年至1992年间在以色列有首次非法医住院且诊断为精神分裂症的所有患者的数据(N = 9081)。还从登记处获取了患者截至1995年的后续住院信息、人口统计学数据及诊断信息。分析对首次住院后的时间、首次住院年龄、原籍国及宗教进行了校正。
12.9%的患者首次住院是非自愿的。首次住院的法律状态与再次住院次数无关。然而,首次住院是非自愿的女性患者再次非自愿住院的可能性是首次住院是自愿的女性患者的4.1倍;男性的这一比值为3.4。进一步分析考察了3420名有四次或更多次住院的患者(慢性病患者)在所有住院中非自愿住院的比例。在首次住院是非自愿的慢性病患者中,后续住院41%是非自愿的。在首次住院是自愿的慢性病患者中,这一比例显著更低,为13%。非自愿住院的比例与住院次数无关。
首次住院的非自愿法律状态与再次住院时的非自愿状态以及随着时间推移非自愿住院次数之间的强烈关联表明,首次非自愿住院可能是评估患者是否可能再次非自愿住院的一个重要因素。