Lund E, Galanti M R
Institute of Community Medicine, University of Tromsø, Norway.
Cancer Causes Control. 1999 Jun;10(3):181-7. doi: 10.1023/a:1008815327004.
The occurrence relation between radioactive fallout from nuclear testing at Novaja Semlja in north-west Russia and the incidence of thyroid cancer in Norway and Sweden was studied following a birth cohort approach.
Birth cohorts with presumably different levels of exposure were identified according to calendar year of atomic tests and previous Norwegian estimates of the population dose (born 1947-1950 received low exposure in late childhood, born 1951-1962 received the highest exposure in early childhood, born 1963-1970 were not exposed). For each one-year birth cohort the incidence rates were calculated, with denominators based on exact population figures for each year of follow-up.
In a stratified analysis, the relative risk for the highest exposed cohorts born 1951-1962, compared to those not exposed born 1963-1970, was found to decrease with increasing age from a borderline significant relative risk (RR) of 1.7 (95 percent confidence interval, 95% CI: 1.0-3.0) for children in the age-group 7-14 years to no excess risk among those 20-24 years of age (RR: 0.9; 95% CI: 0.7-1.2). The mean age at diagnosis of thyroid cancer in the age-group 7 14 years was lowest in the birth cohorts with the highest exposure. The Poisson regression analysis showed essentially the same results, with an improved fit when adding an interaction term between age and birth-cohort to a basic model with age, gender, birth-cohort and country.
These results are compatible with an increased risk of thyroid cancer during childhood and adolescence for subjects exposed to radioactive fallout early in life. Alternative explanations for the pattern of incidence are discussed.
采用出生队列研究方法,研究俄罗斯西北部新地岛核试验产生的放射性沉降物与挪威和瑞典甲状腺癌发病率之间的发生关系。
根据原子试验的历年情况以及挪威先前对人群剂量的估计,确定可能接触水平不同的出生队列(1947 - 1950年出生者在儿童晚期接触水平较低,1951 - 1962年出生者在儿童早期接触水平最高,1963 - 1970年出生者未接触)。对于每个一岁出生队列,计算发病率,分母基于随访各年的确切人口数字。
在分层分析中,发现1951 - 1962年出生的接触水平最高队列与1963 - 1970年出生的未接触队列相比,相对风险随年龄增加而降低,7 - 14岁儿童的相对风险(RR)为临界显著的1.7(95%置信区间,95%CI:1.0 - 3.0),而20 - 24岁人群无额外风险(RR:0.9;95%CI:0.7 - 1.2)。在接触水平最高的出生队列中,7 - 14岁年龄组甲状腺癌诊断时的平均年龄最低。泊松回归分析显示了基本相同的结果,在包含年龄、性别、出生队列和国家的基本模型中加入年龄与出生队列的交互项后拟合度有所改善。
这些结果与生命早期接触放射性沉降物的受试者在儿童期和青春期患甲状腺癌风险增加相符。讨论了发病率模式的其他解释。