Jarde O, Trinquier-Lautard J L, Gabrion A, Ruzic J C, Vives P
Service d'orthopédie-traumatologie, Hôpital Nord, Amiens.
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 1999 Jul;85(4):374-80.
Fifty hallux-valgus were treated with Scarf Osteotomy of the first metatarsal, associated to a phalangeal varisation or shortening osteotomy and an adductor plasty. Patients were evaluated with a minimum follow-up of two years.
Forty five females and two males were operated with an average age of fifty years. The pre operative metatarsus varus was of 15 degrees 8. Mean alignment of metatarsal bar was 31 degrees 4. The cuneo-metatarsal joint was twenty two times spheric and twenty eight times plane. The average metatarso-phalangeal great toe valgus was 39 degrees 8.
They were appreciated with a minimal follow-up of two years, according to the 3 Groulier's criteria: correction of deformation, statics troubles, functional activity. The metatarsus varus improved with an average of 10 degrees 4, as well as the alignment of the metatarsal bar (25 degrees). The post operative average phalangeal valgus was 22 degrees 7. These results were statistically significant. Cuneo-metatarsal joint type did not influenced final result. Articular joint line was normal in 64% of cases. Global result was excellent or good in 70%, passable in 22%, and bad in 8% of cases.
Scarf Osteotomy of the first metatarsal allows complete correction of metatarsus varus. The surgical approach can be proposed at every age. There are no vascular trouble or arthrosis worsening. It must be completed with a phalangeal varisation or shortening osteotomy and adductor plasty.
对50例拇外翻患者行第一跖骨Scarf截骨术,并联合趾骨内翻或短缩截骨术及内收肌成形术。对患者进行了至少两年的随访评估。
45例女性和2例男性接受手术,平均年龄50岁。术前跖骨内翻为15度8。跖骨杆平均对线为31度4。楔骨-跖骨关节22次呈球形,28次呈平面。第一跖趾关节拇外翻平均为39度8。
根据Groulier的3项标准,对患者进行了至少两年的随访评估:畸形矫正、静态问题、功能活动。跖骨内翻平均改善了10度4,跖骨杆对线情况(改善了25度)也得到改善。术后趾骨外翻平均为22度7。这些结果具有统计学意义。楔骨-跖骨关节类型不影响最终结果。64%的病例关节线正常。70%的病例总体结果为优或良,22%为尚可,8%为差。
第一跖骨Scarf截骨术可完全矫正跖骨内翻。该手术方法适用于各年龄段。无血管问题或关节病恶化情况。必须联合趾骨内翻或短缩截骨术及内收肌成形术。