Fuggle S V, Belger M A, Johnson R J, Ray T C, Morris P J
Clin Transpl. 1998:107-13.
A new allocation scheme for kidneys from adult cadaver donors was introduced in the UK on July 1st, 1998. The new scheme is based on data from an analysis of factors influencing transplant survival instigated by the Kidney Advisory Group (KAG) of the UKTSSA. A cohort of 6,363 first cadaver allografts performed in the UK between 1986-1993 was used for the analysis with 99.6% one-year follow-up and 97.8% 5-year follow-up. HLA matching was one of a number of factors that were found to influence transplant survival, thus supporting the policy of exchange of kidneys based on matching. The new allocation scheme is based on 3 tiers in which cadaver organs are offered first in Tier 1 to patients with zero HLA antigen mismatches (000 matchgrade), in Tier 2 to favorably matched patients, (matched for HLA-DR and mismatched for a maximum of one HLA-A and one-B locus antigen -100, 010, 110 matchgrades) and remaining kidneys in Tier 3 to non-favorably matched patients. A points score devised by a subgroup of the KAG to reflect natural justice and common sense is used as a discriminator between equally matched patients. The points are based on recipient age, donor-recipient age difference, waiting time, matchability for HLA antigens, sensitization to HLA antigens and the transplant unit balance of organ exchange. The performance of the scheme will be closely monitored, but computer simulations predict that there will be an overall improvement in transplant survival as a result of an increase in well matched transplants.
1998年7月1日,英国引入了一种针对成年尸体供体肾脏的新分配方案。新方案基于英国移植服务管理局肾脏咨询小组(KAG)发起的一项对影响移植存活因素的分析数据。对1986年至1993年间在英国进行的6363例首次尸体同种异体移植进行了队列分析,一年随访率为99.6%,五年随访率为97.8%。HLA配型是发现的影响移植存活的众多因素之一,从而支持了基于配型的肾脏交换政策。新的分配方案分为三个层级,在第一层,尸体器官首先提供给HLA抗原错配为零(000配型等级)的患者;在第二层,提供给配型良好的患者(HLA-DR配型,HLA-A和HLA-B位点抗原错配最多一个 - 100、010、110配型等级);第三层的剩余肾脏提供给配型不佳的患者。KAG的一个小组设计了一个分数来反映自然正义和常识,作为同等配型患者之间的区分标准。这些分数基于受者年龄、供受者年龄差、等待时间、HLA抗原配型可能性、对HLA抗原的致敏情况以及器官交换的移植单位平衡。该方案的实施将受到密切监测,但计算机模拟预测,由于良好配型移植的增加,移植存活率将总体提高。