Rachlin H
Department of Psychology, State University of New York at Stony Brook 11794-2500, USA.
J Exp Anal Behav. 1999 Sep;72(2):273-7. doi: 10.1901/jeab.1999.72-273.
Mentalistic terms such as belief and desire have been rejected by behavior analysts because they are traditionally held to refer to unobservable events inside the organism. Behavior analysis has consequently been viewed by philosophers to be at best irrelevant to psychology, understood as a science of the mind. In this book, the philosopher Rowland Stout argues cogently that beliefs and desires (like operants such as rats' lever presses) are best understood in terms of an interaction over time between overt behavior and its overt consequences (a viewpoint called teleological behaviorism). This book is important because it identifies the science of the mind with the science of overt behavior and implies that the psychologists best equipped to study mental life are not those who purport to do so but those who focus on the experimental analysis of behavior.
诸如信念和欲望等心理学术语已被行为分析学家摒弃,因为传统上认为它们指的是有机体内部不可观察的事件。因此,哲学家们认为行为分析与心理学(被理解为一门关于心智的科学)充其量是不相关的。在这本书中,哲学家罗兰·斯托特令人信服地论证,信念和欲望(就像老鼠按杠杆等操作性行为一样)最好从公开行为与其公开后果之间随时间的相互作用来理解(这一观点被称为目的行为主义)。这本书很重要,因为它将心智科学与公开行为科学等同起来,并暗示最有能力研究心理生活的心理学家不是那些声称要研究心理生活的人,而是那些专注于行为实验分析的人。