Mittendorf R, Chorzempa L M, Quinlan M P, Herschel M, Williams M A
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Pritzker School of Medicine, University of Chicago, IL, USA.
J Natl Med Assoc. 1999 Sep;91(9):523-7.
This study evaluated whether a new predictive rule is more accurate for estimating the length of pregnancy in African Americans than Nägele's rule, the accepted standard. After identifying women in early pregnancy, telephone interviews were conducted to obtain information about 16 previously established determinants of gestational length. Based on these data, a linear multivariate regression model was used to predict an estimated delivery date (EDD) for each mother. In addition, the EDD was determined using Nägele's rule. Later, the actual delivery date was compared with the EDD predicted by the new rule and with the EDD predicted by Nägele's rule. Each pregnancy was assigned to its better prediction group, either the new rule's group or the Nägele's rule group. Fifty-seven pregnancies were identified prospectively and monitored. The new rule predicted the actual delivery date more accurately in 66% (37/56) of pregnancies, Nägele's rule was a better predictor in 34% (19/56) of pregnancies, and both rules were equally accurate in predicting the delivery date for one pregnancy. The new rule was more precise than Nägele's rule (P = .022) when the binomial distribution was used. When using the linear regression model rule, a more accurate EDD can be determined for African-American women. Moreover, it is possible to predict the risk of preterm delivery (those occurring > 3 weeks earlier than the EDD).
本研究评估了一种新的预测规则在估算非裔美国女性孕期长度方面是否比公认标准——纳格尔法则更准确。在确定早孕女性后,通过电话访谈获取了有关16个先前确定的孕期长度决定因素的信息。基于这些数据,使用线性多变量回归模型为每位母亲预测预计分娩日期(EDD)。此外,使用纳格尔法则确定预计分娩日期。之后,将实际分娩日期与新规则预测得到的预计分娩日期以及纳格尔法则预测得到的预计分娩日期进行比较。每次怀孕都被归入其预测效果更好的组,即新规则组或纳格尔法则组。前瞻性地确定并监测了57例怀孕情况。新规则在66%(37/56)的怀孕案例中更准确地预测了实际分娩日期,纳格尔法则在34%(19/56)的怀孕案例中是更好的预测指标,并且在预测一例怀孕的分娩日期时,两种规则同样准确。当使用二项分布时,新规则比纳格尔法则更精确(P = 0.022)。使用线性回归模型规则时,可以为非裔美国女性确定更准确的预计分娩日期。此外,还能够预测早产风险(那些比预计分娩日期早3周以上发生的情况)。