Pierga J Y, Hoang-Xuan K, Feuvret L, Simon J M, Cornu P, Baillet F, Mazeron J J, Delattre J Y
Radiation Oncology Department, Salpêtrière Hospital, Paris, France.
J Neurooncol. 1999 Jun;43(2):187-93. doi: 10.1023/a:1006262918694.
The benefit of standard treatment of malignant glioma in older patients is debated. In order to assess the effect of a combination of surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy on survival of elderly patients with high grade gliomas, 30 consecutive patients older than 70 years with malignant supratentorial gliomas were studied between 9/93 and 9/96. Median age was 73 years (70-79). The mean Karnofsky performance status (KPS) was 66 (30-100). Patients underwent maximum possible surgery, followed by a course of radiotherapy (45 Gy/25 fractions/5 weeks) with 3 or 4 orthogonal beams and a 2 cm margin around the tumor bed. The administration of chemotherapy was left at the discretion of the responsible physician and 12 patients received reduced dose nitrosourea-based chemotherapy. The overall median survival was 36 weeks. The median time to progression was 26 weeks. Three months after surgery, 26 patients were alive, 5 were in complete response, 2 in partial response and 10 were stabilized. Preradiotherapy KPS was the only significant prognostic factor with a median survival of 40 weeks in patients with KPS > or = 70 and 25 weeks when KPS was < 70 (logrank test, p = 0.05). In responding and stable patients (57% of the group) the median KPS was 68 and 66 at 1 and 3 months after the completion of radiotherapy. There was no case of radiotherapy-induced dementia with this regimen. Four out of 12 patients who received chemotherapy, experienced WHO grade 3/4 hematotoxicity. This study suggest that some patients older than 70 years with KPS > or = 70 may benefit from the treatment of malignant gliomas with surgery followed by reduced dose of limited field radiotherapy. Further studies are needed to define the most appropriate dose of radiotherapy and to evaluate further the risk/benefit ratio of a reduced dose chemotherapy in this population.
老年恶性胶质瘤患者接受标准治疗的益处存在争议。为了评估手术、放疗和化疗联合治疗对老年高级别胶质瘤患者生存的影响,我们在1993年9月至1996年9月期间对30例连续的年龄大于70岁的幕上恶性胶质瘤患者进行了研究。中位年龄为73岁(70 - 79岁)。卡诺夫斯基功能状态评分(KPS)的平均值为66(30 - 100)。患者接受了尽可能大程度的手术,随后进行一个疗程的放疗(45 Gy/25次分割/5周),采用3或4个正交射野,在肿瘤床周围留2 cm的边界。化疗由负责医生酌情决定,12例患者接受了基于亚硝基脲的减量化疗。总体中位生存期为36周。中位进展时间为26周。术后3个月,26例患者存活,5例完全缓解,2例部分缓解,10例病情稳定。放疗前KPS是唯一显著的预后因素,KPS≥70的患者中位生存期为40周,KPS<70的患者为25周(对数秩检验,p = 0.05)。在缓解和病情稳定的患者(占该组的57%)中,放疗结束后1个月和3个月时KPS的中位值分别为68和66。采用该方案未出现放疗诱发痴呆的病例。12例接受化疗的患者中有4例出现世界卫生组织3/4级血液毒性。本研究表明,一些KPS≥70的70岁以上患者可能从手术联合减量的局限性野放疗治疗恶性胶质瘤中获益。需要进一步研究来确定最合适的放疗剂量,并进一步评估该人群中减量化疗的风险/获益比。