Commander M J, Cochrane R, Sashidharan S P, Akilu F, Wildsmith E
Research and Development Unit, Northern Birmingham Mental Health Trust, Erdington B23 6AL, UK.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 1999 Sep;34(9):484-91. doi: 10.1007/s001270050224.
This UK-based study compares the pathways to the psychiatric hospital and the provision of in-patient and after-care for Asian, black and white patients with non-affective psychoses.
Two overlapping samples of 120 patients, 40 from each ethnic group, were drawn; one on admission and the other at discharge. In addition to socio-demographic data, details were obtained on the pathways to care and the in-patient episode. An assessment of needs and service provision was undertaken 3 months post-discharge. Patient satisfaction was ascertained at each stage.
Asian and especially black patients experienced more complex pathways and had higher levels of both involvement with the police and compulsory detention than their white counterparts. They were less likely to perceive themselves as having a psychiatric problem or as needing to go into hospital and expressed less satisfaction with the admission process. Black patients, as compared to Asian but especially white patients, were more often detained in hospital against their will, confined to the ward and treated within a secure environment. However, there were few differences in satisfaction with hospital care. Likewise, perceptions of unmet need, provision of after-care and satisfaction with services were similar across the ethnic groups.
The implications of these findings are discussed. The potential of early intervention programmes and home treatment services to address the ethnic differentials identified in this study merit consideration.
这项基于英国的研究比较了亚洲、黑人和白人非情感性精神病患者前往精神病医院的途径以及住院治疗和后续护理情况。
抽取了两个相互重叠的样本,每个样本120名患者,每个种族群体40名;一个样本在入院时抽取,另一个在出院时抽取。除社会人口统计学数据外,还获取了护理途径和住院情况的详细信息。在出院后3个月对需求和服务提供情况进行了评估。在每个阶段都确定了患者满意度。
亚洲患者尤其是黑人患者经历的途径更为复杂,与警方的接触以及被强制拘留的比例均高于白人患者。他们不太可能认为自己有精神问题或需要住院,对入院过程的满意度较低。与亚洲患者相比,尤其是与白人患者相比,黑人患者更常被违背意愿地拘留在医院,被限制在病房内,并在安全环境中接受治疗。然而,对医院护理的满意度差异不大。同样,各族群对未满足需求的认知、后续护理的提供情况以及对服务的满意度相似。
对这些研究结果的影响进行了讨论。早期干预项目和家庭治疗服务在解决本研究中发现的种族差异方面的潜力值得考虑。