Sipos M L, Burchnell V, Galbicka G
Department of Neurobehavioral Assessment, Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, Washington, DC 20307-5100, USA.
Psychopharmacology (Berl). 1999 Dec;147(3):250-6. doi: 10.1007/s002130051164.
In order to facilitate direct comparisons of anticholinergic drug effects on activity, nine drugs were tested in one laboratory using a standardized procedure.
The present study compared the effects of aprophen hydrochloride, atropine sulfate, azaprophen hydrochloride, benactyzine hydrochloride, biperiden hydrochloride, diazepam, procyclidine hydrochloride, scopolamine hydrobromide, and trihexyphenidyl hydrochloride on activity levels in rats.
Both fine motor activity (reflecting smaller movements) and ambulatory activity (reflecting larger movements) were recorded for 23 h following drug administration in food-restricted rats. All drugs were administered during the light period of the photocycle.
Atropine, azaprophen, biperiden, scopolamine, and trihexyphenidyl increased both ambulations and fine motor activity significantly during the first hour post-injection, but the increased activity levels returned to vehicle control levels within 2-6 h post-injection. Benactyzine and procyclidine only increased fine motor activity significantly above vehicle control levels and activity levels returned to vehicle control levels within 2-3 h. Finally, aprophen and diazepam generally did not increase measures of activity significantly above vehicle controls at the dose ranges examined.
Based on potencies relative to scopolamine, the potency of the drugs could be ranked as follows: scopolamine > trihexyphenidyl > biperiden > azaprophen > procyclidine > benactyzine > atropine > aprophen. The comparison of drug effects on activity may be useful in selecting anticholinergic drug therapies with a minimal range of side effects. In addition, these data may reduce the number of anticholinergic drugs that need to be tested in comparison studies involving more complex behavioral tests.
为便于直接比较抗胆碱能药物对活动的影响,在一个实验室中使用标准化程序对九种药物进行了测试。
本研究比较了盐酸阿普罗芬、硫酸阿托品、盐酸阿扎丙芬、盐酸苯那嗪、盐酸比哌立登、地西泮、盐酸丙环定、氢溴酸东莨菪碱和盐酸苯海索对大鼠活动水平的影响。
在限食大鼠给药后23小时记录精细运动活动(反映较小运动)和自主活动(反映较大运动)。所有药物均在光周期的光照期给药。
注射后第一小时,阿托品、阿扎丙芬、比哌立登、东莨菪碱和苯海索显著增加了自主活动和精细运动活动,但增加的活动水平在注射后2 - 6小时内恢复到溶剂对照水平。苯那嗪和丙环定仅使精细运动活动显著高于溶剂对照水平,且活动水平在2 - 3小时内恢复到溶剂对照水平。最后,在研究的剂量范围内,阿普罗芬和地西泮通常不会使活动指标显著高于溶剂对照。
根据相对于东莨菪碱的效力,这些药物的效力可排序如下:东莨菪碱>苯海索>比哌立登>阿扎丙芬>丙环定>苯那嗪>阿托品>阿普罗芬。比较药物对活动的影响可能有助于选择副作用范围最小的抗胆碱能药物疗法。此外,这些数据可能会减少在涉及更复杂行为测试的比较研究中需要测试的抗胆碱能药物的数量。