Ingram A H
Angle Orthod. 1976 Jul;46(3):219-31. doi: 10.1043/0003-3219(1976)046<0219:PE>2.0.CO;2.
A study was made on 27 cases where enucleation of four first premolars was performed simultaneously without introduction of mechanical devices to influence space closure. The results suggested that: 1. Enucleation of premolars can be used to minimize the severity of crowding in arch-length deficiency cases. 2. There is no damage to the remaining teeth and alveolar process when enucleation is accomplished with good surgical technique. 3. The average amount of lingual tipping of the mandibular incisors in approximately four years subsequent to the enucleation procedure was 4.1 degrees. 4. This amount of lingual tipping compares quite favorably with the amount of lower incisor uprighting experienced during growth and could not be considered excessive. 5. The mandible does tend to rotate in a counterclockwise manner following enucleation of four first premolars without appliance therapy. This rotation was considered significant in comparison with the amount of rotation that could be expected from an untreated sample. 6. If orthodontic treatment is planned, the enucleation of the manddibular second premolars in borderline extraction cases to avoid excessive lingual tipping of the mandibular incisors would seem to be questionable. 7. Various combinations of enucleation and tooth extraction may be helpful in treatment planning. 8. With judicious timing the enucleation of four first premolars can minimize the severity of the malocclusion simplifying appliance therapy if proper diagnosis and good surgical technique are employed. 9. Although conventional serial extraction may accomplish similar ends, it would appear that enucleation would offer some advantages in terms of autonomous adjustment of the mandibular incisors and root positioning of mandibular cuspids. 10. Enucleation cases usually require fewer traumatic surgical procedures and less supervision by the orthodontist. 11. The parents should be informed that serial extraction procedures including enucleation may simplify but will not eliminate the need for appliance therapy.
对27例同时拔除四颗第一前磨牙且未采用机械装置影响间隙关闭的病例进行了研究。结果表明:1. 拔除前磨牙可用于减轻牙弓长度不足病例中的拥挤程度。2. 若手术技术良好,拔除过程不会对剩余牙齿和牙槽突造成损害。3. 拔牙术后约四年,下颌切牙平均舌倾角度为4.1度。4. 该舌倾角度与生长期间下颌切牙直立的角度相比颇为有利,不算过度。5. 在未进行矫治器治疗的情况下,拔除四颗第一前磨牙后,下颌确实倾向于逆时针旋转。与未经治疗的样本预期的旋转量相比,这种旋转被认为是显著的。6. 如果计划进行正畸治疗,在临界拔牙病例中拔除下颌第二前磨牙以避免下颌切牙过度舌倾,这似乎存在疑问。7. 拔牙和牙齿拔除的各种组合可能有助于治疗计划的制定。8. 若时机选择得当,在正确诊断并采用良好手术技术的情况下,拔除四颗第一前磨牙可减轻错牙合畸形的严重程度,简化矫治器治疗。9. 尽管传统的序列拔牙可能达到类似效果,但似乎拔牙在自主调整下颌切牙和下颌尖牙牙根定位方面具有一些优势。10. 拔牙病例通常需要较少的创伤性手术操作,正畸医生的监督也较少。11. 应告知家长,包括拔牙在内的序列拔牙程序可能会简化,但不会消除矫治器治疗的需求。