Boon P, Michielsen G, Goossens L, Drieghe C, D'Have M, Buyle M, Vonck K, Naessens B, De Paemeleere F, Goethals I, Thiery E, Vandekerckhove T, De Reuck J
Department of Neurology, University Hospital Gent, Belgium.
Acta Neurol Belg. 1999 Dec;99(4):247-55.
The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate the diagnostic efficacy and therapeutic relevance of video-EEG monitoring in an large patient population with long-term follow-up.
Between October 1990 and May 1997, 400 patients were monitored at the Epilepsy Monitoring Unit (EMU) of the University Hospital in Gent. In all patients, the following parameters were retrospectively examined: reason for referral, tentative diagnosis, prescribed antiepileptic drugs (AEDs), seizure frequency, number of admission days, number of recorded seizures, ictal and interictal EEG, clinical and electroencephalographic diagnosis following the monitoring session. During follow-up visits at the Epilepsy Clinic, we prospectively collected data on different types of treatment and post-monitoring seizure control.
255/400 (64%) patients were referred for refractory epilepsy. 145/400 (36%) patients were evaluated for attacks of uncertain origin. Mean follow-up, available in 225 patients, was 28 months (range: 6-80 months). Mean duration of a single monitoring session was 4 days (range: 2-7 days). Prolonged interictal EEG was recorded in all patients and ictal EEG in 258 (65%) patients. Following the monitoring session, the diagnosis of epilepsy was confirmed in 217 patients. Pseudoseizures were diagnosed in 31 patients (8%). AEDs were started in 19 patients, stopped in 6 and left unchanged in 110. The type and/or number of AEDs was changed in 111 patients. Sixty patients underwent epilepsy surgery. In 48 surgery patients, follow-up data were available, 29 of whom became seizure-free, and 16 of whom experienced a greater than 90% seizure reduction. Vagus nerve stimulation was performed in 11 patients, 2 became seizure-free, and 7 improved markedly. Of the non-invasively treated patients in whom follow-up was available (n = 135), 70 became seizure-free or experienced a greater than 50% reduction in seizure frequency; 51 patients experienced no change in seizure frequency. Outcome was unrelated to the availability of ictal video-EEG recording. In patients with complex partial seizures, seizure control was significantly improved when a well-defined ictal onset zone could be defined during video-EEG monitoring.
Prolonged interictal EEG monitoring is mandatory in the successful management of patients with refractory epilepsy. Ictal video-EEG monitoring is very helpful but not indispensable, except in patients enrolled for presurgical evaluation or suspected of having pseudoseizures.
本文旨在论证视频脑电图监测在大量患者群体中的诊断效能及治疗相关性,并进行长期随访。
1990年10月至1997年5月期间,根特大学医院癫痫监测单元(EMU)对400例患者进行了监测。对所有患者回顾性检查了以下参数:转诊原因、初步诊断、开具的抗癫痫药物(AEDs)、癫痫发作频率、住院天数、记录到的癫痫发作次数、发作期和发作间期脑电图、监测期后的临床及脑电图诊断。在癫痫门诊随访期间,我们前瞻性收集了不同治疗类型及监测后癫痫控制情况的数据。
400例患者中255例(64%)因难治性癫痫转诊。400例患者中145例(36%)因发作起源不明接受评估。225例患者有可用的平均随访时间为28个月(范围:6 - 80个月)。单次监测的平均时长为4天(范围:2 - 7天)。所有患者均记录到了延长的发作间期脑电图,258例(65%)患者记录到了发作期脑电图。监测期后,217例患者确诊为癫痫。31例患者(8%)被诊断为假性癫痫发作。19例患者开始使用AEDs,6例停用,110例维持不变。111例患者的AEDs类型和/或数量发生了改变。60例患者接受了癫痫手术。48例手术患者有随访数据,其中29例癫痫发作停止,16例癫痫发作减少超过90%。11例患者接受了迷走神经刺激治疗,2例癫痫发作停止,7例明显改善。在有随访数据的非侵入性治疗患者中(n = 135),70例癫痫发作停止或癫痫发作频率降低超过50%;51例患者癫痫发作频率无变化。结果与发作期视频脑电图记录的可用性无关。在复杂部分性发作患者中,当在视频脑电图监测期间能够确定明确的发作起始区时,癫痫控制情况有显著改善。
对于难治性癫痫患者的成功管理,延长的发作间期脑电图监测是必要的。发作期视频脑电图监测非常有帮助,但并非必不可少,术前评估患者或疑似假性癫痫发作患者除外。