Paidi S, Pack A R, Thomson W M
Department of Oral Rehabilitation, School of Dentistry, University of Otago, Dunedin.
N Z Dent J. 1999 Dec;95(422):118-23.
The measurement and reporting of periodontal disease in epidemiological studies can be complex, with the common indices having well-recognised shortcomings. The aim of this study was to illustrate the use of the periodontal loss of attachment (LOA) approach in investigating the association between cigarette smoking and loss of periodontal attachment in a convenience sample of adults, in order to determine whether or not smoking was a risk indicator for periodontal disease. All participants were given a detailed periodontal clinical examination in two randomly assigned contralateral diagonal quadrants, with LOA measurements made at six sites per tooth. Information was also collected on participants' socio-demographic characteristics, oral hygiene practices, smoking history, and attitudes towards smoking. The 240 participants examined comprised 81 current smokers (CS), 79 former smokers (FS) and 80 nonsmokers (NS). Substantial differences and a gradient in disease existed for LOA among the three groups. CS exhibited the greatest (and NS the least) prevalence, extent, and severity of LOA. CS had more plaque and calculus than either of the other two groups, but the groups did not differ with respect to bleeding on probing. Overall, smoking was associated with the disease outcome, and this persisted after potential confounders were controlled using multivariate analysis. Although the observed differences may have been due to the self-selected nature of the sample, the gradient evident across the three smoking exposure groups suggests that smoking cessation can slow the progression of the disease. The LOA approach appears to be a versatile and informative method for recording, analysing, and presenting data on periodontitis in epidemiological studies.
在流行病学研究中,牙周疾病的测量和报告可能很复杂,常用指标存在公认的缺点。本研究的目的是说明在一个方便抽样的成年人群中,使用牙周附着丧失(LOA)方法来调查吸烟与牙周附着丧失之间的关联,以确定吸烟是否为牙周疾病的风险指标。所有参与者在两个随机分配的对侧对角象限接受了详细的牙周临床检查,每颗牙齿的六个位点进行了LOA测量。还收集了参与者的社会人口学特征、口腔卫生习惯、吸烟史以及对吸烟的态度等信息。接受检查的240名参与者包括81名当前吸烟者(CS)、79名既往吸烟者(FS)和80名非吸烟者(NS)。三组之间的LOA在疾病方面存在显著差异和梯度。CS组的LOA患病率、范围和严重程度最高(NS组最低)。CS组的菌斑和牙石比其他两组更多,但三组在探诊出血方面没有差异。总体而言,吸烟与疾病结局相关,在使用多变量分析控制潜在混杂因素后,这种关联仍然存在。尽管观察到的差异可能归因于样本的自我选择性质,但在三个吸烟暴露组中明显的梯度表明戒烟可以减缓疾病的进展。LOA方法似乎是一种用于在流行病学研究中记录、分析和呈现牙周炎数据的通用且信息丰富的方法。