Mannesse C K, Derkx F H, de Ridder M A, Man in 't Veld A J, van der Cammen T J
Department of Geriatric Medicine, University Hospital Rotterdam Dijkzigt, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Age Ageing. 2000 Jan;29(1):79-81. doi: 10.1093/ageing/29.1.79.
To establish the relationship between subjective complaints of side effects of drugs and the objective presence of adverse drug reactions in older patients.
Observational cross-sectional study.
Five medical wards at the University Hospital Rotterdam Dijkzigt.
Patients aged 70 and over admitted to the general medical wards over a 3-month period.
Statistical comparison and Kramer's algorithm.
Of 106 patients, 102 used medication, and 93 of these were able to report whether they believed they were experiencing drug side effects. Thirty-six [39% (95% confidence interval 28.8-48.6)] believed that they were experiencing side effects and the number of diagnoses per patient and the proportion of patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease was higher in these 36 'complainers' than in the group of the 'non-complainers'. We found a correct opinion (true positive and negative) about the objective presence or absence of mild or severe adverse drug reactions in 79% (95% confidence interval 70.2-86.8). Asking the patient about side effects of drugs had a sensitivity of 0.70 and a specificity of 0.85 patients. The severe adverse drug reactions in 21 patients were not recognized by 14 of them.
At hospital admission, older patients should be asked about drug side effects because they are often correct in recognizing them. However, severe adverse drug reactions are not easily recognized.
确立老年患者药物副作用主观主诉与药物不良反应客观存在之间的关系。
观察性横断面研究。
鹿特丹迪克齐赫特大学医院的五个内科病房。
在3个月期间入住普通内科病房的70岁及以上患者。
统计比较和克莱默算法。
106例患者中,102例使用了药物,其中93例能够报告他们是否认为自己正在经历药物副作用。36例[39%(95%置信区间28.8 - 48.6)]认为自己正在经历副作用,这36例“主诉者”中每位患者的诊断数量以及慢性阻塞性肺疾病患者的比例高于“非主诉者”组。我们发现,对于轻度或重度药物不良反应的客观存在或不存在,79%(95%置信区间70.2 - 86.8)的判断是正确的(真阳性和真阴性)。询问患者药物副作用的敏感性为0.70,特异性为0.85。21例患者中的重度药物不良反应有14例未被其识别。
入院时应询问老年患者药物副作用情况,因为他们在识别副作用方面往往是正确的。然而,重度药物不良反应不易被识别。