Supe A N
Department of Surgery, Seth G.S. Medical College, Mumbai.
J Postgrad Med. 1998 Jan-Mar;44(1):1-6.
It is usually observed that medical students undergo tremendous stress during various stages of the MBBS course. There is a high rate of suicide among them.
To determine incidence of stress and factors controlling stress in medical students at various stages of MBBS course at Seth G S Medical college, 238 students (First year 98, Second 76, Third 64) were asked to complete a questionnaire on personal data (gender, stay at hostel, mode of travel, time spent in travel every day, medium of study in school, place of school education.), Stress inducing factors, Zung's depression scale, ways of coping, stress relievers, perceived social support and personality type. Statistical tests used were ANOVA, critical ratio and Student's 't' test.
Majority of medical students (175/238--73%) perceived stress. Stress was found to be significantly more in Second and Third MBBS students rather than First MBBS levels (p < 0.05). Stress was not found to differ significantly on the basis of sex, stay at hostel, model of travel, time spent in travel every day, medium of study in school, place of school education. Stress was found to be significantly more in students having more than 95% of marks at 12th Standard as compared to others. Academic factors were greater perceived cause of stress in medical students. There was no significant difference in the students at different levels of MBBS regarding academic factors and social factors as a stress inducing factors. Physical factors were found to be significantly more in Second and Third MBBS students as compared to First MBBS students. Emotional factors were found to be significantly more in First MBBS students as compared to Second & Third MBBS students. Stress was more common in medical students who have dominant strategy of coping as positive reappraisal, accepting responsibility and planful problem solving. Stress was less common in medical students at Seth G S Medical College who have dominant strategy of coping as escaping and distancing from difficult situation. Family and Friend as perceived social supports were more in Second MBBS than First MBBS medical students. Stress was not found to be significantly more in students having their personality factor contributing to stress (Type A--52/67) as compared to others (Type B--123/171). This indicates that the stress was not trait oriented but was process oriented (p = NS).
Stress in medical students is common and is process oriented. It is more in second and third year. Academic factors are greater perceived cause of stress in medical students at Seth G S medical college. Emotional factors are found to be significantly more in First MBBS. It is dependent on person's ways of coping and social support.
通常观察到医学生在MBBS课程的各个阶段承受着巨大压力。他们的自杀率很高。
为了确定塞思G S医学院MBBS课程各阶段医学生的压力发生率及控制压力的因素,238名学生(一年级98名、二年级76名、三年级64名)被要求填写一份关于个人数据(性别、是否住宿舍、出行方式、每天出行时间、上学时的学习媒介、学校教育地点)、压力诱发因素、zung抑郁量表、应对方式、压力缓解因素、感知到的社会支持和性格类型的问卷。所使用的统计测试有方差分析、临界比和学生t检验。
大多数医学生(175/238——73%)感知到压力。发现二年级和三年级MBBS学生的压力明显大于一年级MBBS学生(p<0.05)。在性别、是否住宿舍、出行方式、每天出行时间、上学时的学习媒介、学校教育地点方面,未发现压力有显著差异。发现12年级成绩超过95%的学生的压力明显大于其他学生。学术因素被认为是医学生压力的更大诱因。在MBBS不同阶段的学生中,作为压力诱发因素的学术因素和社会因素没有显著差异。与一年级MBBS学生相比,发现二年级和三年级MBBS学生的身体因素明显更多。与二年级和三年级MBBS学生相比,发现一年级MBBS学生的情绪因素明显更多。压力在以积极重新评价、承担责任和有计划地解决问题作为主要应对策略的医学生中更为常见。在塞思G S医学院,以逃避和远离困难处境作为主要应对策略的医学生中,压力较少见。与一年级MBBS医学生相比,二年级MBBS学生感知到的家庭和朋友作为社会支持更多。与其他学生(B型——123/171)相比,其性格因素导致压力的学生(A型——52/67)中,未发现压力明显更多。这表明压力不是特质导向的,而是过程导向的(p=无显著性差异)。
医学生中的压力很常见,且是过程导向的。在二年级和三年级更多。在塞思G S医学院,学术因素被认为是医学生压力的更大诱因。发现一年级MBBS学生的情绪因素明显更多。它取决于个人的应对方式和社会支持。