Shi L
Department of Health Policy and Management, Johns Hopkins School of Public Health & Hygiene, Baltimore, MD 21205-1996, USA.
Med Care Res Rev. 2000 Mar;57(1):110-34. doi: 10.1177/107755870005700107.
This study provided a national profile of health insurance of certain vulnerable populations including children, racial/ethnic minorities, low-income families, non-metropolitan statistical area (MSA) residents, and those with poor health status. The study shows an increase in the proportion of uninsured nonelderly population. While public insurance helped reduce the employment- and health-related disparities in private coverage, it has not overcome other disparities related to vulnerable characteristics including race/ethnicity, wages, education, and area of residence. Comparison between health maintenance organization (HMO) and fee-for-service insurance indicates that younger although not much healthier people, racial/ethnic minorities, MSA residents, and those residing in the West and Northeast regions were more likely to have HMO coverage. To reduce significant disparities in health insurance coverage, policy makers will have to consider expanding public insurance coverage, targeting vulnerable groups, particularly those with multiple vulnerable characteristics rather than merely the economically distressed. Expecting managed care to achieve cost containment for services provided to vulnerable populations may be unrealistic.
本研究提供了包括儿童、种族/族裔少数群体、低收入家庭、非都市统计区(MSA)居民以及健康状况不佳者在内的某些弱势群体的全国医疗保险概况。该研究表明未参保非老年人口的比例有所增加。虽然公共保险有助于减少私人保险中与就业和健康相关的差距,但它尚未克服与种族/族裔、工资、教育和居住地区等弱势群体特征相关的其他差距。健康维护组织(HMO)保险与按服务收费保险之间的比较表明,较年轻但健康状况并非更好的人群、种族/族裔少数群体、MSA居民以及居住在西部和东北部地区的人群更有可能拥有HMO保险。为了减少医疗保险覆盖方面的显著差距,政策制定者将不得不考虑扩大公共保险覆盖范围,以弱势群体为目标,特别是那些具有多种弱势特征的群体,而不仅仅是经济困难群体。期望管理式医疗能够实现为弱势群体提供服务的成本控制可能是不现实的。