Martenson J A, Bollinger J W, Sloan J A, Novotny P J, Urias R E, Michalak J C, Shanahan T G, Mailliard J A, Levitt R
Mayo Clinic and Mayo Foundation, Rochester, MN 55905, USA.
J Clin Oncol. 2000 Mar;18(6):1239-45. doi: 10.1200/JCO.2000.18.6.1239.
Randomized studies have suggested that sucralfate is effective in mitigating diarrhea during pelvic radiation therapy (RT). This North Central Cancer Treatment Group study was undertaken to confirm the antidiarrheal effect of sucralfate. Several other measures of bowel function were also assessed.
Patients receiving pelvic RT to a minimum of 45 Gy at 1.7 to 2.1 Gy/d were eligible for the study. Patients were assigned randomly, in double-blind fashion, to receive sucralfate (1.5 g orally every 6 hours) or an identical looking placebo during pelvic RT.
One hundred twenty-three patients were randomly assigned and found assessable. Overall, there was no significant difference in patient characteristics between those receiving sucralfate and those receiving placebo. Moderate or worse diarrhea was observed in 53% of patients receiving sucralfate versus 41% of those receiving placebo. Compared with patients receiving placebo, more sucralfate-treated patients reported fecal incontinence (16% v 34%, respectively; P =. 04) and need for protective clothing (8% v 23%, respectively; P =. 04). The incidence and severity of nausea were worse among those taking sucralfate (P =.03). Analysis of patient-reported symptoms 10 to 12 months after RT showed a nonsignificant trend toward more problems in patients taking sucralfate than in those taking placebo (average, 2.3 v 1.9 problems, respectively; P =.34).
Sucralfate did not decrease pelvic RT-related bowel toxicity by any of the end points measured and seems to have aggravated some gastrointestinal symptoms.
随机研究表明,硫糖铝在减轻盆腔放射治疗(RT)期间的腹泻方面有效。开展这项中北部癌症治疗组的研究是为了证实硫糖铝的止泻效果。还评估了其他几项肠道功能指标。
接受盆腔放疗、剂量至少为45 Gy、每日剂量为1.7至2.1 Gy的患者符合研究条件。患者以双盲方式随机分配,在盆腔放疗期间接受硫糖铝(每6小时口服1.5 g)或外观相同的安慰剂。
123例患者被随机分配并可进行评估。总体而言,接受硫糖铝治疗的患者与接受安慰剂治疗的患者在患者特征方面无显著差异。接受硫糖铝治疗的患者中有53%出现中度或更严重的腹泻,而接受安慰剂治疗的患者中这一比例为41%。与接受安慰剂治疗的患者相比,接受硫糖铝治疗的患者中更多人报告有大便失禁(分别为16%对34%;P = 0.04)和需要防护服(分别为8%对23%;P = 0.04)。服用硫糖铝的患者恶心的发生率和严重程度更高(P = 0.03)。放疗后10至12个月对患者报告症状的分析显示,服用硫糖铝的患者比服用安慰剂的患者出现更多问题的趋势不显著(平均分别为2.3个问题对1.9个问题;P = 0.34)。
硫糖铝并未通过所测量的任何终点指标降低盆腔放疗相关的肠道毒性,而且似乎加重了一些胃肠道症状。