Lohmann C H, Schwartz Z, Niederauer G G, Boyan B D
Department of Orthopaedics, University of Texas Health Science Center, San Antonio, USA.
Orthopade. 2000 Feb;29(2):120-8. doi: 10.1007/s001320050020.
Current methods for articular cartilage repair are unpredictable with respect to clinical success. In the present study, we investigated the ability of cells from articular cartilage, perichondrium, and costochondral resting zone to form new cartilage when loaded onto biodegradable scaffolds and implanted into calf muscle pouches of nu/nu mice. Prior in vitro studies showed that platelet derived growth factor-BB (PDGF-BB), but not transforming growth factor beta-1 (TGF-beta 1), basic fibroblast growth factor, or bone morphogenetic protein-2 promoted proliferation and extracellular matrix sulfation of resting zone chondrocytes without causing the cells to exhibit a hypertrophic chondrocyte phenotype. TGF-beta 1 has also been shown to stimulate chondrogenesis by multipotent chondroprogenitor cells like those in the perichondrium. In addition, PDGF-BB has been shown to modulate chondrogensis by resting zone cells implanted in poly(D,L-lactide-co-glycolide) (PLG) scaffolds. In the present study we examined whether the cartilage formation is dependent on state of chondrocyte maturation and whether the pretreatment of chondrocytes with growth factors has an influence on the cartilage formation. Scaffolds were manufactured from 80% PLG with a 75:25 lactide:glycolide ratio and 20% modified PLG with a 50:50 lactide:glycolide ratio (PLG-H scaffolds). For each experimental group, four nude mice received two identical implants, one in each calf muscle resulting in an N = 8 implants: PLG-H scaffolds alone; PLG-H scaffolds with cells derived from either the femoral articular cartilage, costochondral periochondrium, or costochondral resting zone cartilage of 125 g male Sprague-Dawley rats; PLG-H scaffolds with either articular chondrocytes or resting zone chondrocytes that were pretreated with 37.5 ng/ml rhPDGF-BB for 4 h or 24 h before implantation, or with perichondrial cells treated with PDGF-BB plus 0.22 ng/ml rhTGF beta-1 for 4 h and 24 h. At 4 or 8 weeks after implantation, samples were harvested and analyzed histomorphometrically for new cartilage formed, area of residual implant and area of fibrous connective tissue. Only resting zone cells showed the ability to form new cartilage at a heterotopic site in this study. There was no neocartilage found in nude mice with implants loaded with either articular chondrocytes or perichondrial cells. Pretreatment of resting zone chondrocytes for 4 h prior to implantation significantly increased the amount of newly formed cartilage after 8 weeks and suppressed chondrocyte hypertrophy. The amount of fibrous connective tissue around implants containing either articular chondrocytes or perichondrial cells decreased with time, whereas the amount of fibrous connective tissue around implants containing resting zone chondrocytes pretreated with PDGF-BB was increased. The results showed that resting zone cells can be successfully incorporated into biodegradable porous PLG scaffolds and can induce new cartilage formation in a nonweight-bearing site. Articular chondrocytes as well as perichondrial cells did not have the capacity for neochondrogenesis when implanted heterotopically in this model.
目前关节软骨修复方法的临床成功率难以预测。在本研究中,我们研究了关节软骨、软骨膜和肋软骨静止区的细胞加载到可生物降解支架上并植入裸鼠小腿肌肉袋后形成新软骨的能力。先前的体外研究表明,血小板衍生生长因子 -BB(PDGF -BB)可促进静止区软骨细胞增殖和细胞外基质硫酸化,但转化生长因子β-1(TGF -β1)、碱性成纤维细胞生长因子或骨形态发生蛋白-2却不能,且不会使细胞表现出肥大软骨细胞表型。TGF -β1也已被证明可刺激多能软骨祖细胞(如软骨膜中的细胞)的软骨形成。此外,PDGF -BB已被证明可调节植入聚(D,L-丙交酯-共-乙交酯)(PLG)支架中的静止区细胞的软骨形成。在本研究中,我们研究了软骨形成是否依赖于软骨细胞成熟状态,以及生长因子对软骨细胞的预处理是否会影响软骨形成。支架由80%的PLG(丙交酯:乙交酯比例为75:25)和20%的改性PLG(丙交酯:乙交酯比例为50:50)(PLG -H支架)制成。对于每个实验组,4只裸鼠接受两个相同的植入物,分别植入每只小腿肌肉中,共8个植入物:单独的PLG -H支架;PLG -H支架与来自125 g雄性Sprague -Dawley大鼠的股骨关节软骨、肋软骨膜或肋软骨静止区软骨的细胞;PLG -H支架与在植入前用37.5 ng/ml重组人血小板衍生生长因子 -BB预处理4小时或24小时的关节软骨细胞或静止区软骨细胞,或与用PDGF -BB加0.22 ng/ml重组人转化生长因子β-1处理4小时和24小时的软骨膜细胞。植入后4周或8周,采集样本并进行组织形态计量分析,以评估新形成的软骨、残余植入物面积和纤维结缔组织面积。在本研究中,只有静止区细胞显示出在异位部位形成新软骨的能力。在植入含有关节软骨细胞或软骨膜细胞的裸鼠中未发现新软骨。植入前对静止区软骨细胞进行4小时预处理可显著增加8周后新形成软骨的量,并抑制软骨细胞肥大。含有关节软骨细胞或软骨膜细胞的植入物周围的纤维结缔组织量随时间减少,而含有用PDGF -BB预处理的静止区软骨细胞的植入物周围的纤维结缔组织量增加。结果表明,静止区细胞可以成功地整合到可生物降解的多孔PLG支架中,并能在非负重部位诱导新软骨形成。在该模型中异位植入时,关节软骨细胞和软骨膜细胞均没有新软骨形成的能力。