Lalo S, Rampersa F S, La Borde A, Maharaj K, Sookhai L, Teelucksingh J D, Reid S, McDougall L, Adesiyun A A
School of Medicine, Faculty of Medical Sciences, University of the West Indies, St. Augustine, Trinidad and Tobago.
Int J Food Microbiol. 2000 Mar 10;54(1-2):99-107. doi: 10.1016/s0168-1605(99)00161-0.
In Trinidad and Tobago, raw oyster cocktails are a delicacy, but they are generally believed to be responsible for illness in the consumer. The microbial loads of raw oysters, condiments/spices and ready-to-consume oyster cocktails were determined in four sampling areas. Questionnaires were also administered to 72 oyster vendors to determine practices that affect the bacteriological quality of the products. Three hundred members of the public were interviewed to determine the attitudes, knowledge and perceptions of the public about raw oyster consumption. The mean total aerobic plate count (TAPC) per g of 50 samples each, of raw oysters, condiments/spices and ready-to-consume raw oyster cocktails averaged from 1.0 x 10(7)+/-4.3 x 10(7) to 1.4 x 10(8)+/-6.4 x 10(8), 2.0 x 10(5)+/-1.0 x 10(6) to 2.0 x 10(7)+/-1.4 x 10(8), and 4.3 x 10(5)+/-1.0 x 10(6) to 2.2 x 10(6)+/-1.0 x 10(7), respectively. The difference for each product among the four areas was statistically significant (P < or = 0.05; chi2). Using a recommended maximum standard of TAPC per g of 5.0 x 10(5), 115 (57.5%), 27 (13.5%) and 51 (25.5%) of 200 samples each, of raw oysters, condiments/spices and oyster cocktails, respectively, were considered unfit for human consumption. Amongst vendor practices, source of oyster harvest and length of time between separation of oyster meat from shell and sale, significantly affected the mean TAPC per g and the prevalence of unfit oyster cocktail samples. Consumption of raw oyster cocktails was more prevalent amongst males (73.6%) than females (26.4%) (P < 0.002), East Indians (63.2%) as compared with other respondents (36.8%) (P < 0.001), individuals < or = 40 years old (82.1%) than in individuals > 40 years of age (17.9%) (P < 0.01), and in individuals who were aware that raw oysters are considered to be a sexual enhancer (86.8%) as compared to those who did not have this perception (11.3%) (P < 0.03). Fear of falling ill prevented 44 (37.9%) of 116 non-consumers from eating oyster cocktails, while 13 of 106 consumers (12.3%) reported having experienced an oyster-borne illness. The rather high prevalence of raw oyster cocktails found to be unfit for human consumption, coupled with the perceptions and attitudes of the consumers about the product, pose a significant health risk to the public.
在特立尼达和多巴哥,生牡蛎鸡尾酒是一道美味佳肴,但人们普遍认为它会导致消费者生病。在四个采样区域测定了生牡蛎、调味品/香料和即食牡蛎鸡尾酒的微生物负荷。还对72名牡蛎摊贩进行了问卷调查,以确定影响产品细菌质量的操作。对300名公众进行了访谈,以确定公众对食用生牡蛎的态度、知识和认知。每克50个生牡蛎、调味品/香料和即食生牡蛎鸡尾酒样本的平均总需氧平板计数(TAPC)分别为1.0×10⁷±4.3×10⁷至1.4×10⁸±6.4×10⁸、2.0×10⁵±1.0×10⁶至2.0×10⁷±1.4×10⁸以及4.3×10⁵±1.0×10⁶至2.2×10⁶±1.0×10⁷。四个区域中每种产品的差异具有统计学意义(P≤0.05;卡方检验)。按照每克TAPC推荐的最大标准5.0×10⁵,200个生牡蛎、调味品/香料和牡蛎鸡尾酒样本中,分别有115个(57.5%)、27个(13.5%)和51个(25.5%)被认为不适合人类食用。在摊贩的操作中,牡蛎收获的来源以及牡蛎肉从壳中分离到销售之间的时间长度,显著影响了每克的平均TAPC和不合格牡蛎鸡尾酒样本的流行率。食用生牡蛎鸡尾酒在男性(73.6%)中比女性(26.4%)更普遍(P<0.002),东印度人(63.2%)比其他受访者(36.8%)更普遍(P<0.001),年龄≤40岁的个体(82.1%)比年龄>40岁的个体(17.9%)更普遍(P<0.01),并且在认为生牡蛎被视为性增强剂的个体中(86.8%)比没有这种认知的个体(11.3%)更普遍(P<0.03)。对生病的恐惧阻止了116名非消费者中的44名(37.9%)食用牡蛎鸡尾酒,而106名消费者中的13名(12.3%)报告曾患过由牡蛎传播的疾病。发现不适合人类食用的生牡蛎鸡尾酒的相当高的流行率,再加上消费者对该产品的认知和态度,对公众构成了重大的健康风险。