McElvy S S, Miodovnik M, Rosenn B, Khoury J C, Siddiqi T, Dignan P S, Tsang R C
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, Ohio 45267-0526, USA.
J Matern Fetal Med. 2000 Jan-Feb;9(1):14-20. doi: 10.1002/(SICI)1520-6661(200001/02)9:1<14::AID-MFM5>3.0.CO;2-K.
To evaluate the impact of a focused preconceptional and early pregnancy program specializing in the care of women with Type 1 diabetes on perinatal mortality and congenital malformations.
This clinical study included women with Type 1 diabetes in an interdisciplinary Diabetes in Pregnancy Program Project Grant (PPG) funded by the NIH (1978-1993); these women were enrolled preconceptionally or during the first trimester (up to 14 weeks) and had pregnancies continuing beyond 20 weeks gestation. Strict glucose control was implemented and adherence assessed. Antepartum fetal surveillance was started at 32 weeks gestation. All live-born infants and stillbirths were examined. A retrospective comparison analysis of the period before PPG I (1973-1978) and after cessation of funding (1993-1999) was performed, specifically evaluating perinatal mortality and congenital malformation rates. Data were analyzed using analysis of variance, chi2, and Fisher's exact test.
Three hundred and six women were enrolled in three 5-year periods: PPG I (1978-1983) n = 111, PPG II (1983-1988) n = 103, and PPG III (1988-1993) n = 92. Entry and interval glycohemoglobin A1 concentrations obtained decreased with each consecutive PPG. An emphasis on preconception care began in 1984, with preconception enrollment reaching 23% for PPG II and increasing in PPG III to 37%. As preconception enrollment increased, perinatal mortality rate decreased from 3% for PPG I and 2% for PPG II, to 0% in PPG III, and the congenital malformation rate decreased to a low 2.2% by PPG III. Comparison data collected for the period before PPG 1 (1973-1978) n = 79 revealed a perinatal mortality rate of 7% and a congenital malformation rate of 14%. Also, a postprogram retrospective analysis of the period 1993-1999 (n = 82) revealed an increase in perinatal mortality, with one death compared to none in PPG III, and a congenital malformation rate of 3.65% compared to 2.2% during PPG III. The preconception enrollment for this period decreased (19.5%).
A program emphasizing preconceptional care, strict glycemic control preconceptionally and throughout gestation, and the use of antepartum fetal surveillance was associated with a significant decrease in the rate of perinatal mortality and congenital malformations in infants of women with Type 1 diabetes. However, ongoing improved outcome appears to depend on the availability of funding for a specialized preconception program.
评估一项专门针对1型糖尿病女性的孕前及孕早期重点护理项目对围产期死亡率和先天性畸形的影响。
这项临床研究纳入了参与由美国国立卫生研究院资助的跨学科妊娠糖尿病项目计划资助(PPG)(1978 - 1993年)的1型糖尿病女性;这些女性在孕前或孕早期(至14周)入组,且妊娠持续至妊娠20周以后。实施严格的血糖控制并评估依从性。妊娠32周开始进行产前胎儿监测。对所有活产婴儿和死产进行检查。对PPG I之前(1973 - 1978年)和资助停止后(1993 - 1999年)这两个时期进行回顾性比较分析,特别评估围产期死亡率和先天性畸形率。使用方差分析、卡方检验和费舍尔精确检验对数据进行分析。
在三个5年期间共纳入306名女性:PPG I(1978 - 1983年)n = 111,PPG II(1983 - 1988年)n = 103,PPG III(1988 - 1993年)n = 92。随着连续的PPG,入组时及各阶段的糖化血红蛋白A1浓度均下降。1984年开始重视孕前护理,PPG II的孕前入组率达到23%,PPG III增至37%。随着孕前入组率增加,围产期死亡率从PPG I的3%和PPG II的2%降至PPG III的0%,先天性畸形率到PPG III时降至低水平的2.2%。收集的PPG 1之前(1973 - 1978年)n = 79的比较数据显示围产期死亡率为7%,先天性畸形率为14%。此外,对1993 - 1999年(n = 82)这一时期的项目后回顾性分析显示围产期死亡率有所上升,PPG III期间无死亡,此期间有1例死亡,先天性畸形率为3.65%,而PPG III期间为2.2%。这一时期的孕前入组率下降(19.5%)。
一项强调孕前护理、孕前及整个孕期严格血糖控制以及使用产前胎儿监测的项目与1型糖尿病女性所生婴儿的围产期死亡率和先天性畸形率显著降低相关。然而,持续改善的结果似乎取决于是否有资金用于专门的孕前项目。